The 2006-2008 Tier list

[mario-man]

I want to MM somebody....

Hey, Mario Man, I have a deal. You use Ganondorf or mario, and I'll use Peach ; )

A Ok doc. You got it mane. I choose Mario.

EDIT: Oh, and maybe I'm slightly wrong about Peach...

However, Mario is waaaaaaayy better than Peach. Well, not waaayyy, but still better. I mean, who gets captured and who gets to rescue? You know the answer to that question don't you? OF COURSE YOU DO!!! el oh el

[Binx]

Peach is at a disadvantage vs fox, marth, shiek, and good spammers such as samus ylink link, otherwise she does even and in lots of cases way better than something like i dunno.... all of the rest of the cast.

[slikvik]

i love mariomans logic

[Falco&Victory]

Even if it is an epic fail

AND NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!
DASHIZWIZ RETIRED FROM MELEE! BRONSON!

[mario-man]

Peach is at a disadvantage vs fox, marth, shiek, and good spammers such as samus ylink link, otherwise she does even and in lots of cases way better than something like i dunno.... all of the rest of the cast.
Except Mario..... LOL

i love mariomans logic
I second this statement^^

Even if it is an epic fail

Or not...............:)

[max32090]

fox or falco IS a hard matchup for cf

[KevinM]

Mario-Man...

.....

.......

On second thought nvm

[KevinM]

laggy comp ftl

[Falco&Victory]

Mario-Man...

.....

.......

On second thought nvm

Um, quote for truth?

laggy comp ftl

QFT



Yeah, Mario-Man, it's been 6 years, I think we'd know if Mario was better. He has a bad recovery, can't float, and doesn't have turnips.

[brawlpro]

and...he doesn't have toad in his clothing, but peach doesn't have the cape..which is pretty good...

[Che_Lab]

*imagines toad inside peach's bra and bowls over laughing*

[-Darc-]

My location is almost as cool as yours Che Lab.

[Oskurito]

my location is coller than both of yours XD

[Adi]

I didn't know they had interwebs in Alaska O.O

...

Or in Maine <_<

[Binx]

I didn't know they had interwebs in Alaska O.O

...

Or in Maine <_<

ROFL ROFL ROFL ten chars

[brawlpro]

lol, i say oskurito's location IS coller than any others...south america!!!

[Brookman]

Too seriously? Probably, but I just wanted to make the point that it's easy to selectively interpret tourney results to suit one's opinion while still looking like one is just talking about facts, and I wanted to give a complete explanation of it.

Sounds good to me.

[mario-man]

Yeah, Mario-Man, it's been 6 years, I think we'd know if Mario was better. He has a bad recovery, can't float, and doesn't have turnips.

You haven't seen ME play Mario in the last six years though...I may prove how good he REALLY is. I intend to prove that he's better than everyone thinks.

[Repryx]

Yeah, Mario-Man, it's been 6 years, I think we'd know if Mario was better. He has a bad recovery, can't float, and doesn't have turnips.

BUT he has the Shoryuken.....thats ALL that matters....(Its not the Tiger Uppercut though)

TIGER UP-PER-CUT

[brawlpro]

mario-man...eggz has already proved all that needs to be proven...

[mario-man]

Eggz has more potential than he has shown. I intend to stretch it even further. You know Eggz hasn't won a tourney with Mario. I'm gonna do it.

[brawlpro]

well, hopefully they have n00bs there...lol jk...

[KevinM]

Eggz has more potential than he has shown. I intend to stretch it even further. You know Eggz hasn't won a tourney with Mario. I'm gonna do it.

You haven't seen ME play Mario in the last six years though...I may prove how good he REALLY is. I intend to prove that he's better than everyone thinks.

Noone has seen you play Mario because you've never been to a tournament.. hence the fact that you're probably not going to advance him as far as you may thing because chances are... just like in my first tournament.. you're gonna get raped.. really badly... over and over again.. and then realize that people like Eggz and Brown Mario and other mains are truly taking them as far as they can go because the character doesn't have the moves to cut it in High level metagame.

[axemangx]

Fools! Dont you get it?

There is no tier list. It all depends how skilled you are.

[Cort]

The tier list doesn't take skill levels into account.

Obviously someone who just picked up the game will get constantly raped by anyone with a brain's Kirby/Pichu...

[Pat/Pro]

Fools! Dont you get it?

There is no tier list. It all depends how skilled you are.

I hate when people say retarded things like this. There are cases where you have to be vastly better than someone to beat them if the matchup is bad enough. And certain characters have more favorable matchups. Hence tiers do exist.

[MR.WIGZ]

I hate when people say retarded things like this. There are cases where you have to be vastly better than someone to beat them if the matchup is bad enough. And certain characters have more favorable matchups. Hence tiers do exist.

QFT

thats it.....

[Dylan_Tnga]

Fools! Dont you get it?

There is no tier list. It all depends how skilled you are.

Send this man a free Tires don exits shirt. ASAP

[Echoist]

Just curious...why is Ganon below Mario? If you look at phanna's match up chart, Ganon has far better matchups than Mario. :S

[Dylan_Tnga]

Just curious...why is Ganon below Mario? If you look at phanna's match up chart, Ganon has far better matchups than Mario. :S

I think its because Phanna's match up chart isn't completly accurate. It's a good reference but it's not the be all end all of character matchups.

[Cort]

No, phanna's chart is flawless and without any bias at all. It should replace the tier list.

[Dylan_Tnga]

No, phanna's chart is flawless and without any bias at all. It should replace the tier list.

Your avatar may confuse me, but I wont fall for this one! :laugh:

[Jam Stunna]

Cort's mindgames carry over into real life.

[Brookman]

Fools! Dont you get it?

There is no tier list. It all depends how skilled you are.

I think we should adopt the SRK method when people come into our forums saying absurd things like this.

I believe the first step is everyone getting together and rubbing their ***** together, then we cooperatively neg rep, then we flame the **** out of them till they either a) concede and adopt our point of view b) concede and stop posting or c) concede and commit suicide.

I think C is normally the goal of SRK members, but we should shoot for either a or b in most cases.

[Emblem Lord]

Roflmao!!!!

[MeleeUltimate]

No, phanna's chart is flawless and without any bias at all. It should replace the tier list.

I agree, there is no use doing a tier list of the charaters if you are going to base it on tournoments (PLAYER ABILITIES)

[Binx]

I agree, there is no use doing a tier list of the charaters if you are going to base it on tournoments (PLAYER ABILITIES)

I agree, its also pointless to base tiers on tournament results that are so old, Falco does not take first often anymore, people know how to get around his lasers they didnt then, I think he should be moved down to 4th and just knock the other ones up, go ahead and tie marth and fox for God tier and place shiek falco peach in high tier so we can get people to stop complaining.

[brawlpro]

tiers don't exits....

[Falco&Victory]

No, phanna's chart is flawless and without any bias at all. It should replace the tier list.

Wait, I thought you hated that Peach has no good match-ups. Shouldn't you be in denial?

[Brookman]

Wait, I thought you hated that Peach has no good match-ups. Shouldn't you be in denial?

Your posting privileges have been revoked. From this post onward you must PM me all ideas you'd like to post, to prevent the flood of stupid.