The 2006-2008 Tier list

[KevinM]

KevinM is cool.

He does what he wants.

Yeah man i'm totally http://i170.photobucket.com/albums/u280/KevinMorrissey2008/1311.jpg

[NJzFinest]

Chu exists. And KDJ missed OC3, FCD, Pound 2, and the Evos. (every big tourney in the past 4 months)
Alot of people exist lol, I was just naming the top 3. And nevertheless people such as M2K still tell me that KDJ is still 3rd because despite his absence.
Also, saying Ken can't compete with any of the top players anymore is stupid.
Quote me where I said that....
All I'm saying is that the whole "Ken and Isai" thing=the past. They aren't on top anymore. M2K, PC, KDJ, and Chu (in that order) are.
4th at OC3 ain't bad. Neither is 1st at Evo World, which had absolutely the biggest turnout for any smash tourney ever.
lol, I'm well aware of how well he's been doing sir.


edit: my 4433th post :) (funny number)

[Brookman]

m2k might makes johns, but at the end of the day all he does (along with all the other top players) is improve, which is all that matters.


Even though I think kdj has pretty much completely lost interest in melee he is still the man and is definitely just smart and perfectly technical.

[ZoSo]

There can be bad matchups, but I still hear character johns.

Even Mew2King who uses the 2 best characters in the game has something gripe about, even when he wins.

The top 5 can beat each other just fine, with Falcon doing ok vs the 5.

They all can win.
Falcon does well against Marth and Peach. Fox and Sheik beat him pretty badly. Falco beats him to a lesser extent. I have no interest in arguing with you about this.

The top 4 are definitely in a league of their own. Falcon and Peach are good, but not good enough.

[Brookman]

I remember, a few pages back, when this topic was actually getting decent. Too bad the flood of stupid began again.

*high fives all around*

[Betrayed]

League of their own? I lol'd...

Just... no... just... no...

[Brookman]

Betrayed, I already established that you don't actually know anything about this game, please keep any opinions you may have about the game or the way it's supposed to be played to yourself.

[ZoSo]

League of their own? I lol'd...

Just... no... just... no...
You raise a very persuasive argument.

[Betrayed]

I suppose next you're going to tell me Roy is top tier

[ZoSo]

Seeing as you obviously have nothing substantial to add to the discussion, would you mind not jerking off all over this thread? Thanks.

[Betrayed]

You're so mean, because you know, I'm sure every other post in this topic has been a wealth of information a great help to the community amirite?

[ZoSo]

And I'm sure that's not because of misguided souls like yourself ****ing it up amirite?

[Betrayed]

Find one post in this topic by me before page 244-245, if you can. Anything of value in this thread was discussed LONG AGO, this topic should have been locked LONG AGO. You honostly didn't realize how bad topics like this turn? Honostly...

[Brookman]

discussion is only as good as people discussing.

Hey look, people like betrayed and doodah. Go figure.

[The Mad Hatter]

Its like watching two monkeys throw poop at each other. Kind of entertaining.

[Brookman]

Its like watching two monkeys throw poop at each other. Kind of entertaining.

It's like watching trolls get reported. Always fun.

[Cort]

Honostly guys, honostly.

[ZoSo]

Find one post in this topic by me before page 244-245, if you can. Anything of value in this thread was discussed LONG AGO, this topic should have been locked LONG AGO. You honostly didn't realize how bad topics like this turn? Honostly...
I actually said that this thread should be locked, but seeing as that clearly isn't going to happen, we may as well make the most of it. Right?

Also, I didn't say or even suggest that you ruined this thread single-handedly. I only implied that it was the work of posters with mentalities similar to your own. If you really think this thread is trash and nothing good can come of it, just don't bother posting. Personally, I believe that there's still something to be discussed here.

[The Mad Hatter]

It's like watching trolls get reported. Always fun.

HAHA! Hes going to tell on me! lol

[Bahamut]

Let's just pretend the previous 15 posts never happened.

If this thread doesn't stop sucking, RAPIDLY, I'm giving it the ol' lockdown.

[Cort]

I propose we make this thread suck as hard as possible.

[Brookman]

Maybe lock down would be a good idea, temporarily. Clear the air, then maybe we can get back to discussing how bad peach/falcon are vs. everyone above them.

[Aesir]

lol again this isnt 2005? They all play pretty normal. CHris was telling me they're all pretty good >_> just to flashy.

[Emblem Lord]

Bahamut: Is that even Bahamut in your sig?

Looks like Ultima Weapon to me. >_>

On Topic: Brookman is funny. But he is also a killjoy. Lighten up. lolz. And uhhhhh Fox is better then Marth. Truth.

[JBM falcon08]

emblem lord, you are correct, except i believe it is ultimate weapon and clouds sword is ultima weapon.

[Brookman]

Does anyone think that peach might be able to steal falco's spot?

[KevinM]

Peach steal Falcos?

As in move Falco down below Marth and Peach?

Seems possible with all of Falco's tactics being crushed by the changing metagame... its possible he might drop that far, but not likely.

[Gustav Wind]

2005 was the year of the peach, 2006 was the year of the falco... sure falco's gone down, but what has peach done since to improve? Nothing really.

[Brookman]

Peach steal Falcos?

As in move Falco down below Marth and Peach?

Seems possible with all of Falco's tactics being crushed by the changing metagame... its possible he might drop that far, but not likely.

I was forgetting falco is just below fox. I was thinking of the old tier list where it was fox sheik marth falco peach. Cause that's probably how it should be again. maybe >_>

[BIG-T]

Teir list is BS. If your a good player you can make anybody work for you. Look at Bum, he came outta nowhere with DK and pwnd many. *****es.....

[Dragon_Hawk]

Teir list is BS.
Please leave this thread.

[Brookman]

Agreed @ dragon hawk.

Though I do agree that you can do well with any character, that's not what the tier list says really. So you really present two different points.

A. The tier list is BS.

This is false, while the tier list may not represent the current meta game it is pretty much fact, and it exists for sure. You just misunderstand it's reason for existing.

B. Bum rapes with DK.

This is true.

[KevinM]

Brookman i can't fathom how you are still able to explain this to EVERY single person that has stated the same thing over and over.

Good ****

[BIG-T]

I understand the tier list for what it is but with the tier list is doing is making noobs think the only good characters in the game are the top and high tier characters.

[56k]

The tier list isn't making them think that. The noobs are making themselves think that.

You obviously don't understand the purpose of the tier list. It isn't "who's better than who", though looks can be deceiving.

[NJzFinest]

I understand the tier list for what it is but with the tier list is doing is making noobs think the only good characters in the game are the top and high tier characters.
The only good characters ARE top and high characters. Bum raping with DK doesn't mean DK is a good character, or else you would see numerous DK players raping :psycho:

[spike9407]

The only good characters ARE top and high characters. Bum raping with DK doesn't mean DK is a good character, or else you would see numerous DK players raping :psycho:


GFT
10 char.

[Dragon_Hawk]

I understand the tier list for what it is but with the tier list is doing is making noobs think the only good characters in the game are the top and high tier characters.
That sounds accurate though... the top tiers and high tiers are the good characters. They're the ones that do well.

[TheManaLord]

LOL @ CJ using DK.

Not in 06.


That's cuz you suck at this game.


I still think top tier shoud have been all 5 of the broken characters.


Peach is nowhere near as bad as the other four.

[pkmvodka]

The only good characters ARE top and high characters. Bum raping with DK doesn't mean DK is a good character, or else you would see numerous DK players raping :psycho:

Bum isn't the only one.