Recent content by OutTheCuts

if it's a tie that's definitely fair. Having the same results over more tournaments is obviously harder and should be given more credit. I do think that attendance and previous PR placement should be treated as tie breakers though, and a majority of the time they don't need to be taken into account.

Attendance is certainly something that should be considered. Every tournament someone attends comes with many more chances to lose and gives us a better idea of their actual skill level (across different days, people, and character match ups). If two people had exactly the same records (not at...

Here are the results for this period. Let us know if anything is wrong and we'll try to clear it up. There were a lot of tournaments this period we increased the length of a period by a month so we apologize if we missed anything. March → July (post GC BG July) Period Current Power Rankings...

here are the results recorded so far. Sorry I took a month to respond. Pookie Wins: Outthecuts, Oreo, Wesley, Chevy Losses: Vish, eBay(x2), Odds, TFS(x2)

I think it's pretty likely unless you pick up some significant losses. I should mention that the minimum is now 3 tournaments per period (since periods are now 4 months) though and we have 2 on record for you. There should be an EPG, GC, and SSG monthly coming up though before the period is over.

I don't think it's good for us to use gut feelings. People play worse/better on different days, against different styles, and vs different matchups. At best I can tell you how each of them plays vs my particular Falco and how they play vs their usual competition (which is pretty different). I...

Here are the wins and losses for people on the PR or in contention. Let me know if we've missed anything or if any of the results are wrong. I've omitted losses from SilentWolf and Bladewise to make things easier to read 1) SilentWolf 2) Bladewise 3) Vish 4) Iceman 5) eBay 6) ThePrime #3 Vish...

I'm not against having someone from EWA or Bham on the panel but this shouldn't be about regional representation. I wouldn't want a panel composed members trying to say that people from their area should be higher on the PR when the results don't justify it (as many posts in this thread and...

I'm certainly up for it. I think some criteria should be put in place with regards to who ends up on the panel. Along with making sure the PR gets made, members should have some level of experience and the community needs to be able to trust the panel to be impartial. That being said, I think...

I agree with both of these. 3 months has proven to be pretty short; that could be helped with more tournaments or a PR set system, but for now going to 4 is probably the best short term solution. I think that a panel is a good idea because it would make process of forming the PR a lot simpler...

I think playing for it sets a pretty bad standard. Then anyone who has been on for a while will feel like they're entitled to play for it. What happens when one of the players in question is from EWA or someone's busy for a while after GC? Do we just wait another month for the grudge matches to...

The current system is based off of results over the last 3 months. Specifically who you won/lost to rather than overall placement to reduce the effect of getting a bad/good bracket. Players must attend at least 2 tournaments in a period to be considered. Previous PR standings are also given...

Here's my list. It's not too different from Ebay's 1) SilentWolf 2) Bladewise 3) Vish 4) Iceman I think Iceman's record almost put him over Vish this period and he did win the head to head. His attendance is also a lot higher, which should count for something, but his losses to Cabbage and...

looks good to me. I don't think there's much else to discuss that hasn't been talked about already.

I definitely did consider you. Here's what the comparison looks like when I split the ties up, I also removed chip from Alien's list because he probably counts at top 6. I do agree that moving Alien up is a little weird. Wins over Blake and DJ combo probably shouldn't move him up, and he did...