DG Archive & MVPs

~ Gheb ~ · Aug 8, 2011

WashedLaundry said:
Active scumRyker's even better than active townRyker because no one ever sees you as scum but me. Gah.

Not true.

#HBC | Laundry · Aug 8, 2011

Soupamario said:
yo EE, you're a man of walls and novels, could you give me some advice on how i should approach trying to make a case?

i really feel i get jumbled up and i turn down the wrong paths when i'm trying to convince people or writing a case, but the odd thing is that i major in journalism and actually am taking advanced classes of it (or have been) and i am a good writer.

Only point out what you need to point out. Granted, a lot of this is going to be in context of the game but take Zen's bull**** case on X1 in TTGL. He came into the day saying he was an expert on X1's meta and tried to pull a hugeass reaching case that wasn't even factually true (X1 does tunnel as town) and the more he was pressured on it, the more obvscum he became. I didn't need to go through D1 to find anything more on him (>implying Zen posts anything of worth on D1 ever) because, at that point, all I needed was his terrible, shoddy, stupid bull**** case to know he was scum.

The whole trick to it is to get them down to something that they can't defend. If they can defend against it with something valid (read: not everything is actually valid), then it's a null point. If it can be answered, it's not a good point. You don't want them answering your questions easily, because that's not pinning them. So, when constructing a case, look at your evidence and decide whether or not what you're saying is:
A) actually scummy
B) can easily be answered by a person
C) can be argued out in about five-ten posts.

If you take away anything fitting B and C, and your case still has some actual proof to it, you've got a decent case.

i really hate it when people tell me i can't like post pictures, or have fun with flavor, i do that **** to entertain myself at times, and i need it when i'm writing stuff like that, i have a good sense of humor with things and even in the hardest or serious subjects i like to make myself laugh in the subtlest way possible

i post reaction .gifs all the damn time. tandora got on my *** all of once and i had a reaction to her almost immediately. If anyone tells you off, tell them to knock it off.

however, having played skype maf with you, you tend to hit annoying levels with your faked restrictions. make sure what you're doing is cool or funny but not incredibly overboard. post what you want, and if they start calling you scummy for it, tell them off for it.

#HBC | Laundry · Aug 8, 2011

Gheb_01 said:
Not true.

as ee pointed out, it doesn't mean jack **** if you can't lead his lynch. granted, i should probably amend my statement to saying "no one can ever get you lynched."

#HBC | Dark Horse · Aug 8, 2011

Erupting Burning RYKER!!!!!! (Ryker/Th3kuzinator hydra) MVP for D.Gray Man Mafia

vanderzant · Aug 9, 2011

Soupamario said:
i really hate it when people tell me i can't like post pictures, or have fun with flavor, i do that **** to entertain myself at times, and i need it when i'm writing stuff like that, i have a good sense of humor with things and even in the hardest or serious subjects i like to make myself laugh in the subtlest way possible

Don't listen to them Soup. No matter what, mafia is still a GAME after all, and if you're not having fun you're doing it wrong. It's why taking on the Chuckie persona is so enjoyable for me :chuckle:

.

Sold2 said:
And then the Archive & MVP thread became the "Past game & the other people" thread.

The sign up thread too apparently :cool:

Nicholas1024 · Aug 9, 2011

Evil Eye, you need to play more games. You're the only player I've ever seen that makes longer cases than I do (and as anyone who's read D1 of Time Travelers knows, that's saying a LOT). XD

th3kuzinator · Aug 11, 2011

http://www.smashboards.com/showpost.php?p=13169540&postcount=12931

~ Gheb ~ · Sep 15, 2011

Kuz and July get MvP for FFIX

#HBC | ZoZo · Oct 14, 2011

So why didn't tHe-Man get MVP for TMNT2? We basically ruled that game to the point that the MVP (Dastrn) only shot the right target because of our pushes/arguments etc =/
Thinking it should be Dastrn/tHe-Man yo

Overswarm · Oct 14, 2011

I won that game with both my scummates dying in the beginning and I did it solely on convincing people so

to that

#HBC | ZoZo · Oct 14, 2011

We had you down as scum tho and even pushed

adumbrodeus · Oct 14, 2011

But you guys lost, lol

#HBC | ZoZo · Oct 14, 2011

Due to a modkill + princess kill

I wouldn't call that bad play

adumbrodeus · Oct 14, 2011

Not bad play =/= mvp material, town still lost because of bad play on the part of it's members and you weren't able to seal the lynch, even though you weren't alive when it came down to it.

It takes a really AMAZING performance to get mvp when your faction loses, your was merely good.

And looking at that final lynch, OS lead town like a boss.

Asdioh · Oct 14, 2011

no mvp for upick pokemafia lolololololol

someone needs to rename mvp because

last i checked

it meant "most valuable player" for that game

which has nothing to do with "astounding play"

herpaderp dgames

#HBC | ѕoup · Oct 15, 2011

No MvP for Megaman X.

#HBC | Dancer · Oct 26, 2011

Almost forgot.

No MVP for Awkward Moments mafia.

Although my applause goes out to Kantrip, who I seriously considered giving it to.

Asdioh · Oct 26, 2011

Sworddancer. said:
Almost forgot.

No MVP for Awkward Moments mafia.

Although my applause goes out to Kantrip, who I seriously considered giving it to.

special shoutouts to asdioh, who protected someone correctly for once in his life but it didn't work because scum had SUPER OVERPOWERED ROLES

but not really

JTB · Nov 19, 2011

After much thought, I have decided to give Kuz MVP for higurashi mafia.

#HBC | Ryker · Nov 20, 2011

Man, salt everywhere.

#HBC | Red Ryu · Jan 20, 2012

Fire and Lighting MvP to Brosuke

Raziek · Jan 20, 2012

Shoutouts to RR being the only mod of like the past 12 games to submit his MvP.

Gova · Jan 20, 2012

Swiss wins MVP for Britches and Hose Mafia.

Asdioh · Jan 20, 2012

^ laughed at the times these were posted

Swiss · Jan 23, 2012

Gova said:
Swiss wins MVP for Britches and Hose Mafia.

Not sure if I've got room for another MvP in my MvP cupboard.

Oh go on, I'll take this one too.

ranmaru · Jan 23, 2012

Asdioh said:
special shoutouts to asdioh, who protected someone correctly for once in his life but it didn't work because scum had SUPER OVERPOWERED ROLES

but not really

Nice. I protected a bp who was targeted by mafia anyways. beat that

(inception mafia)

#HBC | Laundry · Jan 26, 2012

I protected the unlynchable Indy in Toohoo maf when Zen tried to NK him for us.

At that point I don't think I cared anymore, I was mostly just ****ing with him.

Axel · Jan 31, 2012

I still should have won that.

Speaking of what I should have won. Pikmafia MvP. Wtf wuz meta-kriby smoking when he gave that out

~ Gheb ~ · Feb 1, 2012

Will the OP actually get an update some time?

Gova · Feb 2, 2012

No MVP Newbie 15: Betty Crocker Mafia

DtJ S2n · Feb 2, 2012

Archive updated. No changes on MvPs.
If I messed up on something, please say it. And also for future reference, please submit all MvPs to this thread.

#HBC | Red Ryu · Feb 2, 2012

Brosuke is supposed to get MvP in Fire and Lightning.

#HBC | J · Feb 2, 2012

I'll be trying to update my thingy of Mafia wins vs. Town wins.

I think Mafia still has the control over Town wins. o.o

vanderzant · Feb 13, 2012

Axel said:
Speaking of what I should have won. Pikmafia MvP. Wtf wuz meta-kriby smoking when he gave that out

Swiss said:
Btw Zen did all the plans, logic, fake claims, fake cases, seeds of doubt, actual thinking and general scum work, I just sat here calling Riddle scum.

Looooool

Swiss · Feb 13, 2012

Oh I miss playing VS Riddle.

Free elo.

#HBC | Dancer · Feb 16, 2012

Don't tell X1 this but I don't get why SRB gave the MVP for Halo mafia to X1 when Swiss was basically the ones that carried us, especially considering how I just abandoned the game without warning.

oh and

No MVP for newbie 16

vanderzant · Feb 16, 2012

Quick Sworddancer! Edit that post, or I'm afraid his ego might explode!

Axel · Feb 17, 2012

vanderzant said:
looooool

: 3

Swiss · Feb 18, 2012

Sworddancer. said:
Don't tell X1 this but I don't get why SRB gave the MVP for Halo mafia to X1 when Swiss was basically the ones that carried us, especially considering how I just abandoned the game without warning.

oh and

No MVP for newbie 16

People often dislike giving me MVP since I have so many.

/Firstworldproblem

Swiss · Feb 18, 2012

vanderzant said:
Quick Sworddancer! Edit that post, or I'm afraid his ego might explode!

DG Archive & MVPs

Life is just a party

Grand Sage of Swag

Grand Sage of Swag

Mach-Hommy x Murakami

Smash Journeyman

Smash Lord

Smash Master

Life is just a party

Shocodoro Blagshidect

is laughing at you

Shocodoro Blagshidect

Smash Legend

Shocodoro Blagshidect

Smash Legend

Not Asidoh

The world is not beautiful, therefore it is.

The nicest of the damned.

Not Asidoh

Live for the applause

Netplay Monstrosity

Red Fox Warrior

Charging Limit All Day

I'm goin' for it!

Not Asidoh

Smash Lord

Smash Legend

Grand Sage of Swag

J|Zεη

Life is just a party

I'm goin' for it!

Stardog Champion

Red Fox Warrior

Prince of DGamesia

Smash Journeyman

Smash Lord

The nicest of the damned.

Smash Journeyman

J|Zεη

Smash Lord

Smash Lord

Information

Network