- Joined
- Jul 24, 2006
- Messages
- 8,559
- NNID
- Tip_Tappers
- 3DS FC
- 1032-1228-5523
Jeez did Acrostic just ninja me blowing the lid off this game?
Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!
You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!
What do you mean by blowing the lid?Jeez did Acrostic just ninja me blowing the lid off this game?
I agree, and it's why I have no f'ing clue why you're doing this.I would argue that if I was mafia, there would be no need for me to character claim and role claim this early in the game. I would also state that I was in a fairly good position with you initially marking me as a 99% townie. Making this claim would clearly be one of the worst possible choices.
It amazes me that you are blatantly prod dodging and have yet to post any real substance.Instinct tells you? How about some evidence there bud.
I'm town. He's claiming that he tracked me and saw me target Tery. I did not do this, so therefore he is lieing and he is scum.Wait, do you have some kind of proof that Acrostic is scum? I'm confused.
Incorrect. I'm persecuting you for doing nothing OTHER than persecuting Tery. There is a big difference. I've made this clear numerous times, you skimming bro?To be perfectly frank, I think its absolutely ridiculous how sold some of you all are on me being scum for persecuting Tery.
Yeah I also said multiple times that your case on him was legit. It's just that you didn't do anything else which is scummy.I ask you, look at the posts I made towards him Day 1. Look at the points I brought up. You may notice no one really arguing against them because they are legit points. Tery had multiple posts that led me to believe he was scum, and when he proved me wrong by claiming Peach and Jailer, that was the end of it.
Yeah I said that. And try again, I'm not suspect of you for being inactive.I don't remember who said it here, but the interesting thing about mafia is you don't know anyone's alignment until after the mod reveals the truth, but some of you seem to have already labeled me as scum for inactivity. If bad timing is a scum tell, then I don't really understand this game..
He wasn't confirmed when you made your case on him. I'm saying from EVERYONE ELSE'S perspective, we don't know if you are town or scum, so we can't know if you're manipulating us or not.SEMI confirmed?! Take a look a few pages back, you'll see that Tery was killed overnight. And what's this? Its Peach, the Jailer! And while you may deem it "near worthless" that I went after all the information I could from a person before I decided if they should be lynched, but it also saved him from being one of the major suspects of the day. Yes, I do wish I had done it differently knowing that I would be outing the Jailer, but I maintain that his posts were bad enough to merit investigation to the best of my abilities.
Wtf? I even did an ebwop like 2 minutes later. You are straw manning the point I was trying to get across that we shouldn't rely on your flavour as evidence. It's like the dumbest thing I've ever seen for crying out loud.Oh so when something is confirmed to be true that I claimed (peach=jailer) by the mod of the game, its foolish to trust what I say now? Now that seems kinda odd. If I'm not mistaken (and I know I'm not, I'm looking at the post right now), you yourself said "The mod also specificly stated that any wrongly recieved pm's have likely been changed"
A very strong, confident statement until the very end there, where you put that little "likely" in there. So while the role PMs very well may have been changed, the one I had was dead on. Only change I'm aware of is that the person receiving it changed.
No no no no no.Like vanilla townie? Seems like then we'd just have to ask what Mario universe character, and watch for the counterclaim. We've already seen Peach and Yoshi, I would bet Mario, Luigi, Bowser, mainstream characters like that should probably show up as well. If someone were to claim to be Goomba, the Vanilla Townie, I would be a bit suspicious of that.
Heh, so you can claim I have contributed nothing and then tell me to settle down while you get to my points huh.
And guess what, if Acrostic is lying about being the tracker he'll be the next one to lynch. He's not stupid, so I feel pretty safe saying he's telling the truth (IE, not throwing his life away to take you down)
Incorrect. I'm persecuting you for doing nothing OTHER than persecuting Tery. There is a big difference. I've made this clear numerous times, you skimming bro?
I thought I made it pretty clear that I had a bunch of stuff come up causing me to become inactive.
Yeah I also said multiple times that your case on him was legit. It's just that you didn't do anything else which is scummy.
I thought I made it pretty clear that I had a bunch of stuff come up causing me to become inactive.
And besides, that makes my entire case against Tery, something that I led myself, totally invalid?
Yeah I said that. And try again, I'm not suspect of you for being inactive.
Really? Because that's the reason I didn't do anything beyond go after Tery.
He wasn't confirmed when you made your case on him. I'm saying from EVERYONE ELSE'S perspective, we don't know if you are town or scum, so we can't know if you're manipulating us or not.
FOR CRYING OUT LOUD I DEFENDED YOU ON THIS POINT!!!! Others were saying you were scummy for using the info in your role pm and I said it's a NULL tell, REPEATEDLY until my fingers hurt from typing it so much!!!!! fffffffffuuuuu this is terrible skimming.
I'm aware of what happened. I'm addressing the points in your posts.
Wtf? I even did an ebwop like 2 minutes later. You are straw manning the point I was trying to get across that we shouldn't rely on your flavour as evidence. It's like the dumbest thing I've ever seen for crying out loud.
Just because 1 pm wasn't changed doesn't mean any others you recieved were.
Changing "likely changed" to "possibly changed" literally has ZERO impact on my post (that there is no certainty that ANYTHING was changed.)
No no no no no.
If that were the case we would of just mass character claimed the second the game started.
Mafia WILL be given safe claims that blend in with the crowd, so the game can't be instantly be won for town by doing a mass claim. Go freaking read the OP I'm sure it says something about not relying on flavour.
Seriously, not relying on flavour is like mafia 101.
Maybe before you decide that I should read the OP, you should take a look at it yourself. There's literally nothing about that in there, my not knowing that has nothing to do with lack of skill, but rather a lack of clairvoyance.
Right now, yeah. At the time of this writing, there are 5 town members and 2 mafia remaining. We know this to be a fact. Unless Acrostic is a townie turned bad, one of the two of you is scum.
What you've done this game
1. Tunnel Tery
Once again, because I thoguht he was scum.
2. Blatantly prod dodge
You mean post in the few times I have free time? Yeah, I suppose I do.
3. Attack 1 of my posts
I had issues with what you said, so I brought them to the attention of everyone else.
4. Not commented on basically everything else that happened yesterDay
I haven't had much time to look over it, I've been focusing on you recently. If you'd like I could glance back over it next time I'm free though.
Let me as you this Glyph, are you content to just lynch me, and if I flip town lynch Acrostic tomorrow? I know it's going to happen... but what then? If you're town you should realise that you will most likely be the 3rd lynch, and thus you would lose the game for town.
PLEASE STOP WASTING YOUR TIME ARGUING WITH THE GUY WHO IS GOING TO GET LYNCHED REGARDLESSY, AND THINK ABOUT HOW YOU'RE GOING TO LYNCH SCUM.
Yo X1, sorry for doing this a second time, but I'm going to replace out.
Acrostic said:I know from first hand experience that scum tells are difficult to apply to first time players who have not read the tips and strategies posted on the mafia wiki. Most of the behavioral rules are true because people are aware of them. In my first game I was town and broke nearly every single one of those rules because no one told me what to read or where to go. Based on Terywj's previous comments before coming into this game, he was reluctant to participate and didn't know anything about mafia beforehand. Therefore I observed his actions as a similar case to my first game of mafia and assumed that he was like me, "This guy is so bad that he can't be mafia."
Acrostic said:I know from first hand experience that scum tells are difficult to apply to first time players who have not read the tips and strategies posted on the mafia wiki. Most of the behavioral rules are true because people are aware of them. In my first game I was town and broke nearly every single one of those rules because no one told me what to read or where to go. Based on Terywj's previous comments before coming into this game, he was reluctant to participate and didn't know anything about mafia beforehand. Therefore I observed his actions as a similar case to my first game of mafia and assumed that he was like me, "This guy is so bad that he can't be mafia."
This is to prevent anything like this happening again. My sincere apologies2.) To unvote, use the command unvote. For example, unvote vote: Sworddancer.. You do not need to unvote before voting again
My responses are in Yellow-Green. Although, I do agree with Glyph. You lied, Acrostic. What do you have to say for yourself?He miscounted which I found was strange. I wanted to clear things up if it was a mistake.
Oh, no that is fine. I appreciate that you did, I even asked for a vote count myself.
Should I have said something? Before that I went through arm and leg to get UberMario to participate. You must understand that I was a bit exasperated at the fact that I tried to get him to really push out but his last response was kind of like 'meh, I dunno' which is not what you say when you are on the verge of getting lynched. It seems like you're trying to accuse me of not trying hard enough for UberMario which is odd since you didn't do much either in order to validate his town role before you decided to vote. I would appreciate your comments on why you didn't reconsider retracting your vote or helping me out if you are going to pay so much attention to the end of the day.
Hmmm? No, you didn't have. I meant you contradicted yourself and I was merely pointing out that you didn't seem to regret that WE -Van, Grump, and me- lynched him and you accidently voted or something. I would have retracted my vote if you asked to. Although Tery also was on the wagon, which you forgot to mention.
I didn't realize I missed his claim until I read MK's post.
Ah, ok, that's fine. Thank you for clearing that up.
I'm not sure which comment you're attempting to reference, but you've done a pretty poor job in wording it correctly. I attempted to clear Uber of town so that we wouldn't mislynch a townie. I tried to get Glyph involved so we could certify his claim and I tried to certify Glyph by checking with Tery in order to work out that claim. Therefore Glyph certified could possibly mean Uber certified if Glyph had the corresponding role pm. I tried my best to prevent him being lynched.
Some of the things I have noted off your play Ranmaru is that you tend to ask us how we are feeling a lot of the time. It seems like you are trying to gain acceptance from town on decisions you are considering and decisions you have already considered. It is a scum tell on the part of mafia to probe town and ask them how they feel about certain decisions that are made in order for them to make appropriate decisions in return. The fact that you have been doing this on a consistent basis in addition to the fact that you are attempting to cast a shadow of a doubt on me when you have suspicions of Glyph make me suspect of your alignment. To be quite honest, I believe that you are the play for today.
No, that's just my playstyle. I never tried to cast a shadow of doubt on you, I was merely pointing out something that was standing out to me.
Vote: Ranmaru