The old test sunk into the depths, so I figured I'd make another. Why is a Lucas/Ness main making a PT elemental knockback test? 'Cause my buddies won't believe me that our numerous electrical attacks are super effective against Squirtle. As it turns out, they're right about the Thunder, however Grass, Fire and Water do have an effect.
I did a low damage and high damage test for each of the three elements in question, searching out the percentage that demonstrated it most clearly. KO's were from the middle of Final Destination with the same damage % for each pokemon. Here are the results.
Fire Test #1 - Mario Forward Smash Uncharged, 110%
Charizard - Survived
Squirtle - Survived
Ivysaur - KO'd
Fire Test #2 - Lucas PK Fire, 270%
Charizard - Survived
Squirtle - Survived
Ivysaur - KO'd
Water Test #1 - Squirtle Up Smash Uncharged, 100%
Charizard - KO'd
Squirtle - Survived
Ivysaur - Survived
Water Test #2 - Squirtle Waterfall every hit connecting, 260%
Charizard - KO'd
Squirtle - KO'd
Ivysaur - Survived
Electricity Test #1 - Lucas Down Smash Uncharged, 85%
Charizard - Survived
Squirtle - KO'd
Ivysaur - Survived
Electricity Test # 2 - Ness PK Thunder, 300%
Charizard - Survived
Squirtle - KO'd
Ivysaur - Survived
Electricity Test #3 - Lucas Up Smash, Fully Charged, 35% (just for fun)
Charizard - Survived
Squirtle - KO'd
Ivysaur - Survived
EDIT: Elemental weaknesses do affect pokemon as follows:
Charizard - Weak against Water-based attacks
Squirtle - Weak against Grass-based attacks
Ivysaur - Weak against Fire-based attacks
Although the tests above do not indicate this, the Thunder weakness is debunked further in the thread, and it's shown that Squirtle is in fact weak against only Grass.
I did a low damage and high damage test for each of the three elements in question, searching out the percentage that demonstrated it most clearly. KO's were from the middle of Final Destination with the same damage % for each pokemon. Here are the results.
Fire Test #1 - Mario Forward Smash Uncharged, 110%
Charizard - Survived
Squirtle - Survived
Ivysaur - KO'd
Fire Test #2 - Lucas PK Fire, 270%
Charizard - Survived
Squirtle - Survived
Ivysaur - KO'd
Water Test #1 - Squirtle Up Smash Uncharged, 100%
Charizard - KO'd
Squirtle - Survived
Ivysaur - Survived
Water Test #2 - Squirtle Waterfall every hit connecting, 260%
Charizard - KO'd
Squirtle - KO'd
Ivysaur - Survived
Electricity Test #1 - Lucas Down Smash Uncharged, 85%
Charizard - Survived
Squirtle - KO'd
Ivysaur - Survived
Electricity Test # 2 - Ness PK Thunder, 300%
Charizard - Survived
Squirtle - KO'd
Ivysaur - Survived
Electricity Test #3 - Lucas Up Smash, Fully Charged, 35% (just for fun)
Charizard - Survived
Squirtle - KO'd
Ivysaur - Survived
EDIT: Elemental weaknesses do affect pokemon as follows:
Charizard - Weak against Water-based attacks
Squirtle - Weak against Grass-based attacks
Ivysaur - Weak against Fire-based attacks
Although the tests above do not indicate this, the Thunder weakness is debunked further in the thread, and it's shown that Squirtle is in fact weak against only Grass.