I read this thread yesterday and I thought it would be a good idea to do an analysis of pikachu and see how he stands up compared to the rest of the crew. I believe the fox boards are also doing something like this. We can evaluate pikachu on many aspects. Read this before continuing:
http://www.smashboards.com/showthread.php?t=199108
Pikachu:
Zoning:
The ratings here go Amazing, Above Average, Average, Below Average, Terrible.
Spacing:
The ratings here go Comfortable, Bearable, Uncomfortable.
Killing:
The ratings here go Amazing, Above Average, Average, Below Average, Terrible.
I have my own thoughts on pikachu through my own playing experience, but I would like to hear what other pika players/"pros" say about him. I will summerize what everyone says after everyone gets a chance to post their thoughts. I don't know how to do that multiple quote thing in one post, so a summery will have to do. Discuss!
EDIT: I am done summerizing pikachu. I score pika 31 out of a possible 37. Mr E gave pika 29 out of 37, and Muhznit score pika 29/37. I guess pika's average score is 30. =P Not Bad!
EDIT 2: I'll update the summery as I get more user inputs, so the rating is not final.
http://www.smashboards.com/showthread.php?t=199108
Pikachu:
Zoning:
The ratings here go Amazing, Above Average, Average, Below Average, Terrible.
- On the Ground - Pikachu does incredibly well on the ground with his arsenal of quick tilts and powerful smashes. Dtilt comes out almost instantaneously with decent range to it. It has a change of tripping your opponent too, which can lead to QAL. His ftilt has some nice knockback and few startup frames, so its good for sending your opponent away to give pika some breathing room. Ftilt has KO potential at higher percents, which is deadly since the move looks deceptively harmless. Utilt is absolutely amazing. The is mainly used my pika players for comboing and it is very quick. Pikachu's fsmash is very powerful and has nice range to it, but it is more powerful near pika's cheeks. Usmash can also kill easily or it can be combo'd into Thunder. Dsmash can kill too, but your opponent can usually DI out of it to avoid the last hit. Pika's throws (with the exception of bthrow) sets up for chain grabs or deadly combos. QAC is great for mindgames and mobility, since it can lead to Thunder, Aerials, and many other things. Pikaslide (isn't the name adorable?) is also worth a mention. It allows pika to slide backwards while jumping, fsmash, shielding, or basically doing anything. Rating: Above Average.
- In the Air - Pikachu's air game is geared towards comboing, rather than powerful finishers like that of snake. As Mr. E said, Fair is the bread n' butter of pika's aerial game. It has little lag on it and it can lead to many combos. Uair is very quick with little knockback, which is perfect for comboing/juggling. Nair has kill potential at higher percents. Bair is also a nice aerial, but fair is usually better that bair. Dair has nice knockback too. Overall pika has a very versitile air game, though not the best, it is defiantly very good. Rating: Above Average
- Off the Stage - As for recovery, pikachu has one of the best recoveries in the game. Skullbash provides huge horizontal distance, thunder can be used to stall pika's aerial momentum, and quick attack can be user to recover vertially, horizontally, or even diangonally! If pika's nair connects with the opponent, the opponent most likely will not make it back. Rating: Amazing
Spacing:
The ratings here go Comfortable, Bearable, Uncomfortable.
- Extremely long distance - At this distance, pikachu can easily outcamp most characters with his tjolt, which probably has the most annoying path of any projectile. He is also a small character than can crouch under most projectiles, so dodging them is a breeze. Pika's Thunder has the 2nd highest vertical range (Snake's fully charged usmash is first), so it can strike opponent way above him who might think they are safe. Perfect for getting star KO's. Pikachu's QAC can close the distance of FD is about 1.5 seconds, so pika is only 2 QAC's away from owning his opponent. Rating: Comfortable
- Long distance - This is pika's best position. his QAC allows him to strike instantaneously with an aerial or thunder, and then retreat to safety. His tjolt is very nice for forcing your opponent in the air, where you can QAC -> aerial to hit them. Again, he can dodge most projectiles with ease at this distance. He is out of range of almost all the physical attacks, so pika remains safe, while in striking distance. Rating: Comfortable
- Medium Distance - Pika doesn't excel at this range, since characters with disjointed hitboxs/huge range (marth, DDD, Ike) can hit pikachu without pika returning the favor. Pika does have some nice range on his attacks however, including Headbutt (neutral A), fsmash, ftilt, and dtilt, so he can hold his own at this distance against characters without broken range (snake, anyone?) Rating: Bearable
- Short Distance - Pika is every effective at this range. His uitlt can set up for combos, his grabs also set up for CG or combos, dsmash is good for clearing an area if you need breathing room. Pika's attacks are fast with decent priority, giving him the edge at close combat. Rating: Comfortable
Killing:
The ratings here go Amazing, Above Average, Average, Below Average, Terrible.
- Killing Power - Pika excels at racking up damage and has nice finishers, but landing the finishers at kill percents takes some work. Occasionally, you can trick someone into a sweetspotted thunder and kill them at 60%, but that is rare in high level play. If pika does land a kill move at 100%, the opponent usually dies.Rating: Average
- Gimping Potential -
Gimping Potential: Quadruple Thunder says hi to those with crappy recoveries. Wavebounced Thunder says "HI, I'M AN ELECTRIC FENCE KTHNXDIE". Thundershock says hi to anyone trying to go under the stage. Too bad reflectors and absorbers screw them over, though. D: Above Average.
I have my own thoughts on pikachu through my own playing experience, but I would like to hear what other pika players/"pros" say about him. I will summerize what everyone says after everyone gets a chance to post their thoughts. I don't know how to do that multiple quote thing in one post, so a summery will have to do. Discuss!
EDIT: I am done summerizing pikachu. I score pika 31 out of a possible 37. Mr E gave pika 29 out of 37, and Muhznit score pika 29/37. I guess pika's average score is 30. =P Not Bad!
EDIT 2: I'll update the summery as I get more user inputs, so the rating is not final.