I can't really debate on Wall-E, I've seen the movie only once and at that I was more or less spending time with my girlfriend then actually watching the movie.
A Bug's Life shows a rather dark theme at the same time. And some quotes are...questionable...while others can be seen as actual facts and based off the bug - the entire movie could be seen in another light.
I wouldn't call it dark. At its heart it is about standing up to injustice and fighting for your personal rights. It is about breaking free from the reigns of an evil leader.
I would want a kid to learn to stick up for themselves. I would want them to know that it is okay to disagree with the status quo imposed by leaders.
Now let's delve into the quotes. My responses are red.
-----------------------------
"Hopper: You piece of dirt! No, I'm wrong. You're lower than dirt. You're an ant! " (The Grasshoppers could represent a larger country, that use the lower country for their supplies. In this case - food.)
And you think its okay that an entire country would be used as a slave force to gather food? I love how the ants rebel against this. Standing up against evil is definitely a morally sound theme.
"Queen: It's the same year after year, they come, they eat, they leave; that's our lot in life. It's not a lot, but it's our life. " (Leader saying live with it? Colony of ants could equate to a country)
The movie shows that it is not okay. The ants rebel against the grasshoppers. A movie has to sometimes present what is wrong to show what is right.
Have fun explaining suicide to your child. I could think of multiple other words that would have fit, hell "idiotic" would have been a better word.
"Queen: Why didn't I think of that? Oh, because it's
suicide. "
I really don't find the word that taboo. Used in this context it was most likely the queen alluding that something was so dangerous that she could die. Yes, I would be okay with a kid seeing that you shouldn't do something that could make you die. The word is not used in context where you would have to explain to a kid that some people hate their lives and choose to end it. Most kids would just process this as meaning "idiotic".
While accurate, even more death:
"Fly:
I only got twenty-four hours to live, and I ain't gonna waste it here. "
Kids know things die. By the time they see this movie they most likely will have personally squashed about 20 bugs themselves. I don't think it is morally wrong to let kids know animals die. That is just common sense.
Still accurate, more death:
"Rosie: And that's
how my twelfth husband died. So, now I'm a
widow. I mean, I've always been a black widow, but now I'm a black widow *widow*. "
See above
Because
this is child appropriate:
"Fly: Hey, cutie!
Wanna pollinate with a real bug? "
You honestly find this offensive? Anyway the word pollinate would make it fly over most kids' heads. As far as sexual innuendos go this is about as tame as it gets
Isn't slavery fun?
"Hopper:
Not one ant sleeps until we get every scrap of food on this island! "
Yes, but the ants rebel against this, which shows how slavery is wrong. That is the point behind the movie.
"Flik: For the colony, and for o
ppressed ants everywhere! "
I'd change the word ants, but then I'd be racist.
I don't get why you included this one. Do you find the word oppressed offensive? Flik stands up against oppression. It is justice!
Because risking your life for your country is brave!:
"Princess Atta: The caterpillar's using himself as
live bait.
Mr. Soil: How brave! "
He didn't risk himself for his country, he risked himself to save the little ant's life (I think her name was dot). It was brave, and dramatic! There is nothing I see wrong here. How bland does the movie have to be to show it to kids? Would you rather the caterpillar sit back and do nothing? Personally, I think that would be less morally sound.
Hey look, bad guy's mother died:
"Hopper: I swear, if I hadn't promised Mother on her
deathbed that I wouldn't kill you, I would kill you!"
Well, looks like on the very last one you got me. I would rather they wouldn't want to kill hopper.
Off topic:, t
This is going to be my new signature:
"Hopper: First rule of leadership: Everything is your fault. "
And those were only
quotes I could find off of:
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0120623/quotes
I'm sure there are some videographic things that could be found offensive. No words needed.
No, there really isn't anything else I would view as offensive, and this is including your quotes. You presented things that were shown to be morally wrong through the movie itself.