How would this change IC gameplay?

[guest]

Would it change gameplay much if you could switch control of climbers midgame? Or if the lead climber was KOd, the player could use the other rather than the 2nd climber suddenly disappearing?

Discuss.​

 

[choknater]

wow, that would be sweet. mostly what it'd do is ice climbers would be the same... except you would be surviving for a much longer time because you're still alive if one gets gimped. yayuhzzzz

 

[Xarias]

No. Horrible idea. It would effectively DOUBLE the IC's lifespan. It would let you do impossible combos, allowing you to instantly control another character on the other side of the stage.

Broken beyond belief. It'll never happen.

 

[choknater]

No. Horrible idea. It would effectively DOUBLE the IC's lifespan. It would let you do impossible combos, allowing you to instantly control another character on the other side of the stage.

Broken beyond belief. It'll never happen.

but it would be sweet, would it not?

show some love <3 (for nana)

 

[KiddyDong]

IC in melee were nearly broken with desynching, allowing you to play Nana even after Popo is KOed wouldnt just be broken, it would be shattered glass broken.

 

[choknater]

IC in melee were nearly broken with desynching, allowing you to play Nana even after Popo is KOed wouldnt just be broken, it would be shattered glass broken.

They weren't even close to broken in Melee. Desynching is actually an inefficient and risky tactic on its own, and only feasable after grabs. The rest is all flashy.

Being able to play Nana after Popo died wouldn't change a thing, it'd just make them a lot harder to gimp, and therefore harder to kill. But honestly it wouldn't change where they'd stand as a character.

But that bit about being able to switch control... yeah, that is pretty nasty.

Shattered glass broken? Not quite.

I'm just looking forward to double spicy curry for my FIRE CLIMBERS

 

[The Hypnotist]

I would make it so if Popo died you could play as Nana solo. I would also make their grab have more range.

 

[shinhed-echi]

Even as a fellow Ice Climbers mainer... I wouldn't like that...

At MOST it should allow you to control Nana before she disappears. (Like say, deliver a smash attack at your opponent after Popo is koed, before Nana disappears, for a surprise attack. )

Another thing is... I hope they fix their UP+B move.. it was possibly one of the WORST recoveries in the game. (Considering its failing ratio). Been using these guys for a while, and I STILL don't know what it takes for their UP+B to work.

Being close is not alaways enough...

 

[Cereal Rabbit]

Reminds me of the DK Country series. The "taking turns" idea is a great idea. Not really that broken. I guess it is. We just have to wait until the game is out!

 

[prinnykurtis]

In melee, if popo is falling off the stage , i just start jamming the c stick and and try to get a ko with nana. It really catches people off guard.
Being able to control both would be seriously broken. Extending the lifespan of the ics would be hugely unfair advantage.

 

[N1c2k3]

Another thing is... I hope they fix their UP+B move.. it was possibly one of the WORST recoveries in the game.

LoL. I guess it's the worst b/c it goes higher than any other in the game, or something? Yeah, that makes sense. You have to make sure Nana isn't in the tumbling animation for it to work, if that's what you were referring to in the last part of your post. C'mon man, know what you're talking about before wasting our time...

 

[Smasher89]

considering they can DI some attacks on like D64 to close 200% (which might be more in brawl) it would be kinda fun but broken, because like if nana is on stage and your opponent gets after popo who is recovering and KO him, it would switch to an imidiate edgeguard from Nana and possibly an edgehog/f/dsmash.
And ruining Nana mindgames (at least like half off them) would be kinda sad. (random smash after KO ftw XD)