@Glyph. How did you get that Nich was scum from your gambit? If anything, I'd say his reaction was null at best. Also, what did you think of Ryker planning to tunnel on Kanty because Kanty was trying to save Nich? What are your thoughts on Kanty now? When Legolas says that you haven't blatantly scum-hunted, I have to agree. Almost all D1 you focused on Nich and, right now, I'm not sure who you're going for. If you have made it clear and I just do not see it, tell me and I will re-read. Otherwise, who do you think could be scum?
I was analyzing his tone more than anything else. He was already in an agitated state due to the Ryker back and forth, that much was very clear. I anticipated a shot pushing him over the edge as town and causing a big explosion of anger.
But instead all of his anger vanish and he was extremely laid back about being killed. It was a complete 180 from his previous MO. On top of that he made several posts that contained lines hinting he was suspicious the shot wasn't real, but never outright said it. All in all, seemed like he wanted to come off as town just in case the shot WAS fake.
I've actually addressed the Kantrip push in that giant post I just made, and I think Kantrip is extremely scummy for exactly that reason. As for not scumhunting, I worked with what was available to me when I was posting. That was almost entirely Nich and Ryker. Most other players would be sure to pop in and say 'yeah! go team' or whatever but rarely actually did anything worth analyzing. The few times that something caught my eye, I made note of it (Gova and Raziek come to mind, though at this point I don't want to lynch either of the two).
Right now I am looking hard at a Kantrip lynch, and have not been a fan of another player that I'm going to hold off on talking about for a bit.
Glyph I read that whole thing, it doesn't fix the issues people had with you. How the only person I've seen you make frontward progress was Nich and your reads during the situation didn't move fluidly. I can't tell much how you gained from your gambit of even why it was necessary in that situation. You didn't really attempt to scum hunt or look into other players for connections. Even when EE tells me to look for one scum at a time you should still pay attention to the roaster. Which I'm not sure about your reads on anyone else.
RR, I want you to tell me
exactly what issues people have with me that I did not address. I want you to explain how my reads not moving fluidly (ie, not documenting every change in them) makes me scum. I want you to read my post where I explain EXACTLY why I did the gambit and why it was necessary for me. In said post, you'll also find answers to, well, everything else you are saying I didn't do here.
