I had a long post written out, but my computer froze
A lot of people seem to be either losing interest or finding other reasons not to come to tournaments. I'm okay with a smaller, close-knit group of players, but I think we should rethink our priorities as a community. If we want to legitimately work on getting better, then I think we should block any impediments to that. As cheap as the ASL already is, money is still a huge issue for a lot of players, and I would like to eliminate that as a factor. In short, I think we should host free entry tournaments. We could still have a venue fee when necessary, but we get rid of entry fees and prize money.
Most people don't benefit from the money situation as is, only a handful benefit in fact. I certainly don't mean to chastise them for that, but I think we need to shift our priorities to helping everyone improve. We could save our money so we can go to larger out of state tournaments, which could help us improve, grow closer as a group, and let people know we exist.
Frankly, every argument I've heard in favor of keeping prize money doesn't appear to hold water. I've heard people say that nothing is on the line in free tournament. I don't think people are going to stop trying because the tournament is free; if nothing else, pride is on the line. I've heard people say that top level players won't come to tournaments if there's no money involved. While I agree to some extent, we are talking about local tournaments, not regionals. I'm confident our good players like the game enough to come regardless of the prize money. If we ever do host a large tournament, we should have prize money, but we don't need it at locals. I'm willing to listen to anyone who thinks they can argue for prize money. However, as of now, I only see money as an impediment.
I was going to recommend that we get rid of the PR as well, but after talking to Billy, I don't think that's a good idea. The PR can be a huge distraction to players who want to get "just good enough" to maintain their spots (I'm guilty of this too). It also forces players to cut each other down and argue every few months about who is better. As much as I don't like that, I think it serves other vital functions. It shows other states that we are active, and it helps us seed tournaments more effectively. We might consider restructuring the PR to fix the problems without getting rid of the benefits. Currently I have no suggestion to do that, but it's something to think about.