I personally found Prima's supposed "Official" Guides to be crap. And then Nintendo Power, or so I heard, has stopped making their guides. So, uh, yeah. They make mistakes like this. All of the time. I doubt you can find one without mistakes.
Yeah, I
hate Prima. I have their Animal Crossing (original) guide, it is horrible. There are spelling errors, and for every holiday (Thanksgiving, Toy Day, Halloween, you name it) it tells you that you get an item if you've kept your town nice all year. That's not true for
any holiday. I've had bad experiences with other guides of theirs as well.
Prima knows way more about Smash then you guys. I have no idea why these people in the Smash Back Room are making the tier list anyways. They have zero credibility unlike Prima.
...Are you kidding? Like, seriously?
Prima sucks at strategy guides. I'm sure I could write up a better guide than them. The people in the Smash BRoom may not be part of some company but...at least they aren't idiots.
Fixed.
My friend has that, all I remember is that under ddd, it says something along the lines of, "DeDeDe has many strengths, but one big weakness- He's very tough to KO due to his great recovery."
Hilarity ensued.
Wow, that's an epic failure. Honestly, do they have copy editors? That in addition to the "Maria" mistake just shows that they clearly don't work that hard on their guides, or they don't have copy editors.
I was in FYE a while ago and I saw the Brawl guide and picked it up to read it, just to see what was in it...yeah, it was pretty facepalm-worthy. They said Lucario had a bad recovery because his Extremespeed can only go straight up. I'm sure a 5 year-old could figure out that you can go in different directions.
I believe they also made a pretty lulzy mistake on Samus's page, but I can't remember it...maybe someone who owns the guide knows.
guy.