How accurate is the SBR's final melee tier list?

[Supernova757]

I thought it was totaly perfect because the main problem I found with the eariler one was that it had Marth on 4th spot which didn't make much sense. But, now they moved him to 2nd, which makes a lot of sense. {Well atleast it does to me} Tell me what you guys think of it? Do you think their should be any correction, etc...


For those of you that heven't seen it yet:

Top
Fox 9.9
Marth 9.9
Sheik 9.7
Falco 9.2

High
Peach 8.4
Captain Falcon 8.0
Jigglypuff 8.0
Ice Climbers 7.9

Middle
Samus 6.8
Dr. Mario 6.2
Ganondorf 6.0
Luigi 5.8
Donkey Kong 5.4
Mario 5.3

Low
Link 4.7
Pikachu 4.3
Young Link 4.2
Roy 3.6
Zelda 3.0
Game and Watch 3.0

Bottom
Ness 2.5
Yoshi 2.5
Bowser 2.2
Mewtwo 1.8
Kirby 1.5
Pichu 1.2

 

[lordXblade]

I feel falco should be around 9.4 or 9.5, and falcon around 8.2. Ignoring the points, however, the actual rankings are perfect.

 

[Wind Owl]

lmao this is such a terrible topic

 

[Megavitamins]

Marth isnt 2nd, hes tied for first with Fox. The numbers are there for a reason, lol.

 

[KevinM]

Wow there is a sticked topic to discuss the Melee tier list... so we make a thread to discuss the Melee tier list.