Mario as top tier?

[Mario_ 101]

What do you guys think? I mean, in gimpyfishes impressions thread, he said that everything about mario improved from melee and that he was might've been the best character at the demo. It'd be awsome if he is.

 

[Ca$hoholic]

Mario is the ultimate all around character, anyone can use him, and he do what he do!
because of that he must be in the middle...

Still.. i hate tiers!

 

[W.Jr]

well anything is possible, since mario has several new moves. Though i doubt top tier, maybe mid tier.

 

[DalzK]

i dont use him but wud be nice seeing him as a top tier :D

 

[mario brawler]

I hate tiers but most likely mid-tier,but if you really read gimpy's thread he alos say's almost all the character were playable at the same level and that no one character was far better than another with Ike being an exeption(hope they fix him )

 

[E-Jolteon]

I'd say mid-tier, since Mario is as standard as it comes.

 

[Lootic]

any character who dont have this kind of thread?

 

[S2]

I doubt Mario is going to be a top tier. He just plays too, "normal".

That is, Sakurai made a very specific choice to have him be an easy to play, all-around character.

With the exception of his cape, none of his moves really lend themselves to overly abusive strats. Like always, I'm sure he'll be a very decent character that is either mid or high on the tier list.

But like usual, I'm sure one of the stranger playing characters will end up being top tier.

 

[mario-man]

You guys seriously need to check Gimpyfish's thread of impressions!!!

He has a statement something like this "In Melee, Mario was the all-around good character, but in Brawl he is the all-around GREAT character." then later he says "Mario fans rejoice!! He is greater than his Melee counterpart in EVERY respect"

Seriously ppl, if that doesn't sound like a top tier character, then you 1st) need to go read Gimpy's thread for a more detailed description and 2nd) if you still don't think so, then go get your brain checked. He also specifically said that Mario was deffinitely one of the best characters in the demo.

I will give you guys some grace and say that he may only be towards the top of high tier, which is waaay better than middle of the mid tier.

sorry if this sounds harsh, I'm not trying to really degrade anyone at all. Just trying to help build the excitement for the Plumber and ultimately, Brawl itself.

 

[mario8498]

I think you are all underestimating Mario. If held in a master, he can be better than fox, falco, bowser, jiggs, anyone.

 

[mario-man]

In Brawl yes, but not Melee. In Melee it comes down to the mental side that makes Mario better, though I do think he was underestimated in Melee. Oh, and what's up with adding Bowser and Jiggs along with Fox and Falco?? Bowser and Jiggs suck really bad in Melee. LOL

 

[mario8498]

In Brawl yes, but not Melee. In Melee it comes down to the mental side that makes Mario better, though I do think he was underestimated in Melee. Oh, and what's up with adding Bowser and Jiggs along with Fox and Falco?? Bowser and Jiggs suck really bad in Melee. LOL

Hardly man. And Mario could've been the best in Melee. Like you said, it's mental. The right mindset and Mario is a beast.

 

[mario brawler]

You guys seriously need to check Gimpyfish's thread of impressions!!!

He has a statement something like this "In Melee, Mario was the all-around good character, but in Brawl he is the all-around GREAT character." then later he says "Mario fans rejoice!! He is greater than his Melee counterpart in EVERY respect"

Seriously ppl, if that doesn't sound like a top tier character, then you 1st) need to go read Gimpy's thread for a more detailed description and 2nd) if you still don't think so, then go get your brain checked. He also specifically said that Mario was deffinitely one of the best characters in the demo.

I will give you guys some grace and say that he may only be towards the top of high tier, which is waaay better than middle of the mid tier.

sorry if this sounds harsh, I'm not trying to really degrade anyone at all. Just trying to help build the excitement for the Plumber and ultimately, Brawl itself.

I have read the impresion just because he said all that does'nt mean he's gonna be top tier,I CAN see him in top tier but I would'nt be suprised seeing him back at mid-tier,mario was improved tho,but it also said in the thread that brawl was much more balanced than melee meaning players can play at a more equal level than having boswer fight C.Falcon in melee,honestly I don't even see the purpose of a tier list for brawl,they just help cheap player's chose a character just because he's/she's top tier/NOTE:I main mario he is my favorite video game character of my life time,incase you might think I'm being bias...

 

[mario-man]

Okay whatever lol

just making sure you knew about that thread. Going by the SPECIFIC description of Mario by Gimpy, it seems to me like he would be at least high in the high tier. This is all of course hinging on wether they change any physics from the demo to the actual release. But then we could start debating wether or not WDing still has a chance to return and I don't wanna go there right now....

 

[mario-man]

AARRGGHH!!! double post accidental

 

[D Athier]

Honestly, I like the idea that Mario has been improved, but I'm not really sure how much I would like it if he became a top tier character. Mario Mains are rare, because he's mid tier, and that's one reason why I like him. Not many people use him, and that makes you unique.

Then again, my game could only improve if he was high tier, right?

 

[mario-man]

true, you have a point, but I think that Brawl is gonna be alot more balanced. So, even if Mario is high tier, it won't matter cuz every other character will be almost just as good, which completely nullifies this discussion. lol

 

[Smashbros_7]

He's been buffed by ALOT! Have you seen his up B from that Online video(smashbros). It's FAR!!!, Fludd is bad, but fun to use! And his fire balls have higher priority!

 

[MarioMasterz34]

true...The Coin Jump has been upped alot! Mario should'nt be an underestimated character. he could be just as good as the rest. Fludd should not have replaced the Mario Tornado. Using it as the drill kick is weird. it will make a diffrence because i use the drill kick in melee alot so the legnth of the MT will be too laggy.

 

[mario brawler]

Okay whatever lol

just making sure you knew about that thread. Going by the SPECIFIC description of Mario by Gimpy, it seems to me like he would be at least high in the high tier. This is all of course hinging on wether they change any physics from the demo to the actual release. But then we could start debating wether or not WDing still has a chance to return and I don't wanna go there right now....

well Wdashing is pretty much out,im pretty sure Sakurai knew about Wdashing and probably I dunno did'nt like it cuz the game was never meant to be played like that lol,with the new physics enginge it'd be impossible

 

[mario-man]

well Wdashing is pretty much out,im pretty sure Sakurai knew about Wdashing and probably I dunno did'nt like it cuz the game was never meant to be played like that lol,with the new physics enginge it'd be impossible

yeah well, you may notice that I said if they changed the physics. so,.....yeah LOL they probably won't but you never know what they'll do, though I'd think that would take too much time to do in just a month unless they've already been doing it.

true...The Coin Jump has been upped alot! Mario should'nt be an underestimated character. he could be just as good as the rest. Fludd should not have replaced the Mario Tornado. Using it as the drill kick is weird. it will make a diffrence because i use the drill kick in melee alot so the legnth of the MT will be too laggy.

Umm, I've heard that the MT has almost no lag time AND throws the opponent up in order to be a combo move like the drill kick.

 

[MarioMasterz34]

if someon doesnt get hit and mario is done spinning like a madman? what about his hitboxes?

 

[mario-man]

I don't know about his hitboxes. All I know is that if you hit them it throws them up and has a lot less lag compared to Melee, but it also is no longer usable for recovery.

I like your sig btw

 

[MarioMasterz34]

Thanks you(not a typo) I think they thought of replacing the Mario Tornado's recovery with the super long coin jump punch

 

[Smashbros_7]

Mario IS Top tier AND the best at E for all. This has been confirmed by gimpy and other pros!

 

[SlayerOfEvil]

Wasn't mario on the bottom of the high tier list in Melee? If so, dunno why people are saying he's mid....

 

[mario-man]

uhh no, he was middle to low on the middle tier.

 

[JJJ.Brawler]

Tiers need to stop...being made. UNLESS someone creates a good CASUAL-player tier.

Then, yes. Mario would have a strong chance. I think.

Wow, awesome idea, there should be 2 tiers, one for tournament players like the current Melee tier, and one for casual gamers like me, that are in fact good, but do not like seeing people "ShInE SpIKe" -WTF.


Although, I do wavedash all the time.

Oh yeah, and I made a 'casual' tier list and Fox still ended up first, so it wouldn't change that much. The list took me about 3 weeks to make. Well, Fox + Captain Falcon were first. And NO it was not biased. I hate Fox.

 

[MrOtter]

Tiers need to stop...being made. UNLESS someone creates a good CASUAL-player tier.

Then, yes. Mario would have a strong chance. I think.

Wow, awesome idea, there should be 2 tiers, one for tournament players like the current Melee tier, and one for casual gamers like me, that are in fact good, but do not like seeing people "ShInE SpIKe" -WTF.


Although, I do wavedash all the time.

Oh yeah, and I made a 'casual' tier list and Fox still ended up first, so it wouldn't change that much. The list took me about 3 weeks to make. Well, Fox + Captain Falcon were first. And NO it was not biased. I hate Fox.

... Dude, wait. What?

 

[REDRAGON]

In Brawl yes, but not Melee. In Melee it comes down to the mental side that makes Mario better, though I do think he was underestimated in Melee. Oh, and what's up with adding Bowser and Jiggs along with Fox and Falco?? Bowser and Jiggs suck really bad in Melee. LOL

Hardly man. And Mario could've been the best in Melee. Like you said, it's mental. The right mindset and Mario is a beast.

lol Mario fanboys....
Man, all the fanboys say "Omg my character is underestimated". lol
Whats wrong with having a bad character???
Btw Mario was not underestimated at all

Redragon

 

[REDRAGON]

Tiers need to stop...being made. UNLESS someone creates a good CASUAL-player tier.

Then, yes. Mario would have a strong chance. I think.

Wow, awesome idea, there should be 2 tiers, one for tournament players like the current Melee tier, and one for casual gamers like me, that are in fact good, but do not like seeing people "ShInE SpIKe" -WTF.


Although, I do wavedash all the time.

Oh yeah, and I made a 'casual' tier list and Fox still ended up first, so it wouldn't change that much. The list took me about 3 weeks to make. Well, Fox + Captain Falcon were first. And NO it was not biased. I hate Fox.

What in the world?!?!?

Sorry for the double post, but i had to comment on this fools post....
Dude, you need some help lol casual gamers?!?!

 

[mario-man]

dude redragon, yes he was. I may be a fanboy, but I avoid being blinded by it.

 

[A2ZOMG]

Mario as top tier is the best news ever.

Mario is like the best character ever. He freaking deserves to be top tier.

BTW, if Melee Sheik can be overpowered AND easy to use, why not Brawl Mario? Mario by far is the more important character so he should really be the better fighter anyway because he's freaking Mr. Video Game.

 

[JJJ.Brawler]

What in the world?!?!?

Sorry for the double post, but i had to comment on this fools post....
Dude, you need some help lol casual gamers?!?!

How am I a fool?

I'm not a fool...

 

[Gerudo Warrior]

response to thread title: that would be sweet victory.

 

[A2ZOMG]

How am I a fool?

I'm not a fool...

There is no such thing as a tier for casual gamers btw.

Tiers in games represent the results of people who have broken down the game step by step and brought characters to their best performance. And in Smash, those are tournament results. There is no way there could possibly a tier for casual gameplay.

 

[mattc1231]

ugh haven't any of you seen eggz play with mario!?!! whatever tier people place him in mario players will still be able to dominate with him

 

[jc1sttwin]

I think Mario deserves to be a Top Tier

I'll play with him no matter what

 

[fazares]

http://smashboards.com/showthread.php?t=141632
this guy is slamming mario....i tried telling him about gimpyfish impressions but he keeps saying mario has been downgraded!!!!!
i think a lack of decent mario players in front of him+a characters bias is doing that....
what do u think?

 

[Chzrm3]

You guys should be wary of subscribing to the views outlined in an 'impressions' thread so quickly. A character's 'tier' isn't determined by being able to pick up the game out of the box and 'pawn face' with him, it's after months of people perfecting every nuance of the character and finally realizing his true potential.