Tom Bombadil
Smash Journeyman
I'm making a short video on basic recovery options with each of the characters. I was thinking of giving each character a loose rating based on the main attributes of recovery which, as I see them, are,
- Distance
- Safety
- Options
I decided to do it report card style and assign letter grades to each attribute as well as an overall grade. For those not in the US, the grades are (from best to worst): A, B, C, D, F with an option + or -
Here's my first draft of a list. I'd love comments and suggestions
Falcon :
- Distance : D
- Safety : C
- Options : F
- Overall : D
DK
- Distance : B
- Safety : B
- Options : D
- Overall : C
Samus
- Distance : B
- Safety : A
- Options : A
- Overall : A
Kirby
- Distance : A
- Safety : C
- Options : A
- Overall : B+
Jigglypuff
- Distance : A+
- Safety : C
- Options : B
- Overall : B+
Luigi
- Distance : A
- Safety : D
- Options : A+
- Overall : B
Mario
- Distance : A
- Safety : A
- Options : A+
- Overall : A
Pikachu
- Distance : A+
- Safety : C
- Options : A+
- Overall : A+
Ness
- Distance : A
- Safety : F-
- Options : C
- Overall : F
Fox
- Distance : D
- Safety : F
- Options : B
- Overall : D+
Yoshi
- Distance : B
- Safety : A+
- Options : A
- Overall : A
Link
- Distance : F
- Safety : C
- Options : F
- Overall : F
That makes the final order (sorted by overall grade):
Best
Worst
Proposed changes:
Fox
- Distance : B (up from D)
- Safety : D (up from F)
- Options : B
- Overall : C (up from D+)
suggestion by Shears but these changes are not the exact ones he proposed
Kirby
- Distance : A
- Safety : B (up from C)
- Options : A
- Overall : A (up from B+)
Jigglypuff
- Distance : A+
- Safety : B (up from C)
- Options : B
- Overall : A (up from B+)
in accordance with Star King's reasoning
Link
- Distance : F
- Safety : D (down from C)
- Options : C (up from F)
- Overall : F
reasoning from Grahamaglam showed me that I had underestimated Link's projectiles during recovery and also attributed points incorrectly
- Distance
- Safety
- Options
I decided to do it report card style and assign letter grades to each attribute as well as an overall grade. For those not in the US, the grades are (from best to worst): A, B, C, D, F with an option + or -
Here's my first draft of a list. I'd love comments and suggestions
Falcon :
- Distance : D
- Safety : C
- Options : F
- Overall : D
DK
- Distance : B
- Safety : B
- Options : D
- Overall : C
Samus
- Distance : B
- Safety : A
- Options : A
- Overall : A
Kirby
- Distance : A
- Safety : C
- Options : A
- Overall : B+
Jigglypuff
- Distance : A+
- Safety : C
- Options : B
- Overall : B+
Luigi
- Distance : A
- Safety : D
- Options : A+
- Overall : B
Mario
- Distance : A
- Safety : A
- Options : A+
- Overall : A
Pikachu
- Distance : A+
- Safety : C
- Options : A+
- Overall : A+
Ness
- Distance : A
- Safety : F-
- Options : C
- Overall : F
Fox
- Distance : D
- Safety : F
- Options : B
- Overall : D+
Yoshi
- Distance : B
- Safety : A+
- Options : A
- Overall : A
Link
- Distance : F
- Safety : C
- Options : F
- Overall : F
That makes the final order (sorted by overall grade):
Best
Worst
Proposed changes:
Fox
- Distance : B (up from D)
- Safety : D (up from F)
- Options : B
- Overall : C (up from D+)
suggestion by Shears but these changes are not the exact ones he proposed
Kirby
- Distance : A
- Safety : B (up from C)
- Options : A
- Overall : A (up from B+)
Jigglypuff
- Distance : A+
- Safety : B (up from C)
- Options : B
- Overall : A (up from B+)
in accordance with Star King's reasoning
Link
- Distance : F
- Safety : D (down from C)
- Options : C (up from F)
- Overall : F
reasoning from Grahamaglam showed me that I had underestimated Link's projectiles during recovery and also attributed points incorrectly
Last edited: