i buncha people have been asking me so i guess i'll post my thoughts
i think SW's vid is a lot better than mine overall. much better and cleverer editing, a **** song and much cleaner clips. (almost all noiseless wavelands, very smooth waveshines)
the main difference between our vids is that his is based on routines and mine is freestyle. his clips are shorter but way cleaner and deliberate. my clips are pretty much random, for each scene i have an idea of what i want to do (shortened phantasm edge cancels, shield drop to edge cancels etc) and the rest is just freestyle.
as for the difficulty of the clips, his have a lot of creativity (waveshine double turnarounds, shine phantasm edge cancels) but we both use new and rarely seen techniques (for me running shield drops, for him shine platform cancels.) some of my clips **** some of his in terms of difficulty, and some of his blow some of mine out of the water.
after watching them both like 20 times i really like both of them for different reasons, but SW's is probably better overall.
it's whatever tho, i'd like to think of us as contemporaries instead of rivals (oh and he's without a doubt a more technical player than me), and our 2-man tech skill video we make at TP4 is gonna **** both of these anyway.