The Best Commentators?

[kozimoto]

Ok, many of you noobies that first read this are gonna be live "Why the **** is this under tactical?" and i'll ask you, is there not a tactic on how people commentate matches? (wether their style is serious or funny) AND the way people commentate matches can either make the players piss their pants laughing or just piss them off. either way it can effect the outcome of the game.

As i watch vids from tournies. I noticed that there haven't really been any good commentators since the MLG days. sure there may be a few exceptions such as Waffles from the west coast.

My question to you is who do you think the best commentators are? My vote goes to da K.I.D of Rochester, New York. His style is just awesome.


Commentators from Melee and Brawl are viable in this thread .

 

[kozimoto]

Reserved....

 

[kozimoto]

Reserved....

 

[tocador]

BEst comentators:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8YGKHFjXPis the guy from this vid and

Eddie from melee :B

 

[sasook]

I heard SamuraiPanda's a good commentator.

 

[bobson]

What, for Brawl?
Didn't you hear? All the cool people are playing Melee.

 

[The Sauce Boss]

Samurai Panda is the best commentator for sure.

 

[kozimoto]

What, for Brawl?
Didn't you hear? All the cool people are playing Melee.

Im open to commentators from both games.

this is not turning into a Melee vs. Brawl thread.......................

 

[AvoiD]

Sky`.

Gives me a boner when he commentates.

 

[kozimoto]

BEst comentators:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8YGKHFjXPis the guy from this vid and

Eddie from melee :B

lol, this guy is just captain obvious

 

[ShadoFiend]

Sky is the best Commentator by far

 

[MarKO X]

SamPan is a good ESPN commentator, but I find him boring.
He wins with info though.

Personally, I like Sky and DJNintendo's commentary. KID is a pretty legit commentator as well.
And of course, the "Melee Guy" lol
the guy in the vid mentioned is also a very excellent commentator and should commentate more often.

 

[da K.I.D.]

ok, heres my thoughts.

I am an AMAZING commentator but i dont quite think im the best

Sky is amazingly funny, but im on his level. but Im the best out there that doesnt cuss.

DJnintendo is a beast. hes funny as hell.

SamuraiPanda is ok, but his commentary is only thought to be amazing cus the first time he did commentatry was on a stream that didnt have any video. SPs commentary is amazing for radio, but when it comes to play by play (a certain style that some people have) i dont think its really necessary for brawl streams

theres this guy in vegas, his name is rabbi, he does play by play but his is amazing cause he commentated on SiN (Smash in Nevada) and hes knows almost nothing about smash so he would say stuff like calling up airs up smashes and b moves, tilts, which was just rofl. so his commentary was great to listen to

DMG also has some pretty beast commentary but its can get annoying cause he tends to repeat the same stuff over and over, so he really shouldnt be allowed to commentate on more than 2 brawl sets in a row.

 

[bobson]

This thread is worthless without videos.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8YGKHFjXPis the guy from this vid and

This guy is the best commentator until further notice.

 

[Juggleguy]

Brawl: SamuraiPanda, WTP ("the guy from this vid")
Melee: Waffles, Phil, DJ Nintendo, Wife

 

[ScubaF_ingSteve]

Brawl: SamuraiPanda, WTP ("the guy from this vid")
Melee: Waffles, Phil, DJ Nintendo, Wife

^^^^^

I agree 10000%

 

[PhatyCHONG]

Homemadewaffles!

 

[kozimoto]

ok, heres my thoughts.

I am an AMAZING commentator but i dont quite think im the best

Sky is amazingly funny, but im on his level. but Im the best out there that doesnt cuss.

DJnintendo is a beast. hes funny as hell.

SamuraiPanda is ok, but his commentary is only thought to be amazing cus the first time he did commentatry was on a stream that didnt have any video. SPs commentary is amazing for radio, but when it comes to play by play (a certain style that some people have) i dont think its really necessary for brawl streams

theres this guy in vegas, his name is rabbi, he does play by play but his is amazing cause he commentated on SiN (Smash in Nevada) and hes knows almost nothing about smash so he would say stuff like calling up airs up smashes and b moves, tilts, which was just rofl. so his commentary was great to listen to

DMG also has some pretty beast commentary but its can get annoying cause he tends to repeat the same stuff over and over, so he really shouldnt be allowed to commentate on more than 2 brawl sets in a row.

K.I.D. r u coming to A taste of Buffalo on 8/1???

I would say its you for East Coast and Waffles for West

and SamuraiPanda and WTP in Midwest

 

[AvariceX]

Best Brawl commentators are SamuraiPanda (we all remember COT4), and MDK.

MDK Commentary vids:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RbYL-t5pfZ0
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mSRuBAWHOUw
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-t29GysLQqM
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uTJ0JX_rl9s


Sky is the worst Brawl commentator I've ever heard actually. Good Melee commentator for sure, but all he does when commentating Brawl is b**** about Brawl not being as good as Melee.

 

[demonictoonlink]

Black people are always the best...

 

[Flipstar]

The guy that commented SIN, Rabbi i think it was, was really really good, although he knew nothing of smash. He was just really professional, it was amazing

 

[Kuraudo]

Geed would make an amazing commentator.

 

[Mota]

Anyone know the names of the guys who gave us WOMBO COMBO?

Happy feet guy >_<

EDIT:

BEst comentators:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8YGKHFjXPis the guy from this vid and

Eddie from melee :B

LMAO epic commentary. Makes watching Brawl slightly fun

 

[jpl315]

Brawl: SamuraiPanda, WTP ("the guy from this vid")
Melee: Waffles, Phil, DJ Nintendo, Wife

this is correct

 

[kackamee]

No one has mentioned Afro's commentary? He did it like once at Apex, that stuff was hilarious.

 

[MarKO X]

Black people are always the best...

See? Sometimes, stereotypes are good.

 

[superyoshi888]

Anyone know the names of the guys who gave us WOMBO COMBO?

Happy feet guy >_<

EDIT:
LMAO epic commentary. Makes watching Brawl slightly fun

This. Every match should be commentated on by these guys.

 

[Matador]

Slikvik....Junebug...

MD/VA, get at meh

 

[OverLade]

MDK
Sky
GamedragonX
Slikvik
Darkpeach....yes I said it
Samuraipanda

 

[Laem]

'the guy from this vid' = WTP(is who? xD) is god tier, can any1 supply links including said people? (sure, post wombo combo, we'll just kill you quickly)

 

[choknater]

lol brandon is famous for his commentary now, too good

ahhh <3 his early vids on his channel were of modesto ppl

PARK

the roots son

 

[kr3wman]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=843AovFJg-I

Ooooh and he's a moron for not grabbing that ledge.

 

[Demp]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_6q3Xoeh4qI

Amazing...

 

[Matador]

Oh yeah, and MD/VA's TKO definitely.

Probably the best at juggling commentating and interacting with the livestream chatroom too.

 

[OFY]

Waffles is the best.

 

[da K.I.D.]

the wombo combo dude is probably the best commentator ive ever heard. Like its not just that one video either, if you watch any of his vids hes rediculously hilarious

 

[Seagull Joe]

Oh yeah, and MD/VA's TKO definitely.

Probably the best at juggling commentating and interacting with the livestream chatroom too.

u forgot me matador. me+tko commentated. why am i left out

 

[The Sauce Boss]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_6q3Xoeh4qI

Amazing...

LOL soooooooooooo bad.

 

[kozimoto]

the wombo combo dude is probably the best commentator ive ever heard. Like its not just that one video either, if you watch any of his vids hes rediculously hilarious

I would agree, I was watching this vid where Mango Screeches SS at a really low % and than Waffles and a chorus of 1000 others go "OH MANGO YOUR SOOOOO GOOOOD!!!!!!" its halarious

 

[Pr0phetic]

Hands down SamuraiPanda and Blackanese.