Mmmk...
In your "handwritten" example, you fail to acknowledge that the other student didn't have access to a computer. The same goes for Roith. And, if one doesn't have the same resources as another, and yet still writes something comprehensive and able to be appreciated, then I say job well done. Also, this is not a classroom... once again, may I point out that this is an internet forum. People don't CARE about grammar, and it is extremely hypocritical of you to belittle this guide for that.
You say that Roith's guide is plagiarized off of the guides of others... this guide was one of the first ones compiled. And, not only that, but this isn't about posting what information YOU have found about Ike--it's about posting UNIVERSAL information about Ike, therefore giving the readers a better idea of how to play Ike. It's not like Kirk has copyright laws for how much damage Ike's Ftilt does.
And if you think that Kirk's and Zareidriel's guides are slowly being buried underneath nonsensical topics about Ike, then you are very wrong. Kirk and Zar are two very respected individuals within the Ike community, and are admired for their work. Thusly, their guides are far from being shunted into a dark corner.
As for you being an illiterate moron... I'm not the one calling you that, UrbanDictionary is. And, if you had gone to the URL that I posted along with the quote, you would have noticed that not only does UrbanDictionary think that you are an illiterate moron, but 547 other people think so, as well.
Content-wise, this guide is more universal. As I pointed out earlier, that's how a guide SHOULD be. It provides links to other guides for a greater understanding of Ike play, it has everything categorized well... Just because its sections aren't colored as prettily as Kirk's or written in as large a font doesn't mean that its badly organized. As for presentation, I've already addressed this: in an internet forum, no one really cares.
This guide has brought a better understanding of Ike to an enormous majority of the Ike-board-goers, and therefore is very well understood BY EVERYONE.