The Rebooted Evolving SSB Roster Game

[darkvortex]

(Waluigi) (Paper Mario)(Dixie Kong) (Ashley)
(King Rauru) (Midna)(Raven Beak)
(Bandana Waddle Dee)(Meowscarada) (Zoroark)
(Lyn) ( \ )(Oatchi)(Octoling)(Porky) (Karate Joe)
(Ring Fit Adventurer)(Tom Nook) (Isaac) (Sami) (Chun-Li) (Dr. Eggman) (Alucard) (Crash Bandicoot) (Master Chief) (Kratos) (Jill Valentine) (Rayman)

Went all third parties for this one

 

[Pupp135]

Here are the nominations:

Pupp135

(Midna)(Veyle)(/)(Noah)
(Bandana Waddle Dee)(Tinkaton)(Tom Nook)
(Octoling)(Ring Fit Trainee)(Isaac)(Bomberman)(Master Chief)
(Chun-Li)(Tails)(Rayman)(Tidus)(Sans)

BritishGuy54
[Paper Mario]

[Octoling][Impa]
[BWD]
(//Pneuma)[Rex][Noah]
[Meowscarda][Ring Fit]
[Lyn][Alear]
[Chun-Li]
[Zero][Dr. Eggman][Shadow]
[Rayman]

nirvanafan
(Capt Toad)
(Gholdengo)(Genesect)(Diancie)(Urshifu)(Arceus)(Gardevoir)
(King Rauru)(Impa)(Ravio)
(Raven Beak) (Krystal)(Ayumi)
(Magalor) (Oatchi)
(Nooklings)(KK Slider)(Spring Man)
(DJ Octavio)(Big Man)(Dragaux)
(Alear)(Sami) (/)(Mio)
(Shadow)(Eggman)(Tails)(Knuckles)(Kiryu)(FF14 Warrior of Light)(2B)
(Chun Li)(M. Bison) (Shantae)
(Crash)(Dingodile)(Master Chief)(Doom Slayer)
(Lara Croft)(Hayabusa)

BowserKing

Fawful,
Dixie Kong, Ashley, Midna, Mipha,
Dark Meta Knight, Bandanna Dee, Susie, and Krystal
Sceptile, Glaceon, Excadrill,
Boltund, Dragapult, Tinkaton,
Tom Nook,
Tails, Amy, Knuckles, Zero,
Spider Jockey and Shantae

Otoad64 (This is last round‘s roster)
(Captain Toad)(Waluigi)(Ashley)(Dixie Kong)
(Impa)(Tingle)(Bandana Waddle Dee)
(Gengar)(Heracross)(Zoroark)(Tinkaton)(Lyn)
(Oatchi)(Tom Nook)(/)(Callie & Marie)
(Chibi-Robo)(Dragaux)(Tails)(Shadow)(Zero)(Chun-Li)(Doom Slayer)


darkvortex

(Waluigi) (Paper Mario)(Dixie Kong) (Ashley)
(King Rauru) (Midna)(Raven Beak)
(Bandana Waddle Dee)(Meowscarada) (Zoroark)
(Lyn) ( \ )(Oatchi)(Octoling)(Porky) (Karate Joe)
(Ring Fit Adventurer)(Tom Nook) (Isaac) (Sami) (Chun-Li) (Dr. Eggman) (Alucard) (Crash Bandicoot) (Master Chief) (Kratos) (Jill Valentine) (Rayman)

DragonRobotKing26
(King Boo) (Midna)(Ashley)
Dixie Kong(Bandana Waddle Dee)(Adeline & Ribbon)
(Krystal)(Heracross)(Gardevoir)(Zoroark)(Hatterene)(Meowscarada)
(Octoling)(DJ Octavio)(Porky Minch)(Rex)(Lip)(Isaac)
(Bomberman)(Alucard)(Chun-Li)(Arle)(Tails)(Rayman)(Master Chief)

Louie G.

(Excitebiker)
(Oatchi) (Chorus Kids)
(Ogerpon) (Lyn)
(Tom Nook) (Octoling) (Off The Hook) (Ring Fit)
() (Solaire) (Tails) (Knuckles) (Arle)
(Chun-Li) (Jill) (Leon)

ninjahmos
(Geno)
(Dixie Kong)(Waluigi)

(Quaxly)
(Karate Joe)(Ring Fit Trainer)
(Bill Rizer)
(Shadow)(NiGHTS)(Arle Nadja)(Kazuma Kiryu)
(Chun-Li)(Arthur)(Phoenix Wright)(Dante)
(Tidus)(Lloyd Irving)(Crash Bandicoot)(Travis Touchdown)(Rayman)
(Doom Slayer)(Master Chief)(Ryu Hayabusa)(Lara Croft)

Vote for your three favorites, where yours is not first.
1. Louie G.
2. BowserKing
3. Darkvortex

 

[DragonRobotKing26]

1. Darkvortex
2. Myself
3. Louie G

 

[BowserKing]

1.Dragonrobotking26
2.Mine
3.Nirvanafan

 

[nirvanafan]

Louie G
Myself
Pupp135

 

[ninjahmos]

1. Louie G.
2. BritishGuy54
3. Pupp135

 

[BritishGuy54]

1. Louie G.
2. Myself
3. Pupp

 

[darkvortex]

1. Bowserking
2. Me
3. Britishguy

 

[Louie G.]

1. Pupp
2. Myself
3. darkvortex

 

[Pupp135]

Here are the votes

Pupp135 6
BritishGuy54 5
nirvanafan 3
BowserKing 7
Otoad64
darkvortex 7
DragonRobotKing26 5
Louie G. 15
ninjahmos

Louie G. wins this round, and Bowserking and Darkvotex tie for second. Louie G. gets 5 points, and BowserKing and darkvortex get 3 points.

Spoiler: Leaderboard

1. Louie G. 77
2. OToad64 31
3. Pupp135 24
4. Northsouthmap 21
5. Darkvorex 16
6. Nirvanafan 8
7. DragonRobotKing 6
8. BritishGuy54, BowserKing 3
10. Ninjahmos

Round 20: Cut 20 characters. The caveat is that none of the fighters added in round 19 can be cut.

Spoiler: Fighters that cannot be Cut

Pupp135: Jigglypuff, R.O.B., Toon Link, Rayman, Sans
BritishGuy54: Dr. Mario, Toon Link, Mii Brawler, Hero, Steve
Nirvanafan: Diddy Kong, Simon Belmont, Ravio, Gardevoir, Ryu Hayabusa
BowserKing: Lucas, Bowser Jr., Aegis, Dark Meta Knight, Sceptile
Darkvotex: Master Chief, Kratos, Jill Valentine, Rayman, Terry
DragonRobotKing26: Banjo & Kazooie, Ashley, Adeline & Ribbon, Meowscarada, DJ Octavio
Louie G.: Bowser Jr., Duck Hunt, Banjo & Kazooie, Terry, Steve
Ninjahmos: Snake, Wolf, Wii Fit Trainer, Terry, Kazuya

My list (It got hard after the first 10 cuts).

(/)
(Tinkaton)
(Octoling)(Ring Fit Trainee)
(Chun-Li)(Rayman)(Tidus)(Sans)

Spoiler: Cuts

Rosalina
Bowser Jr.
Daisy
King K. Rool
Sheik
Midna
Bandana Waddle Dee
Greninja
Lucina
Byleth
Veyle
Tom Nook
Noah
Min Min
Duck Hunt
Isaac
Bomberman
Snake
Tails
Master Chief

Spoiler: Reasons

I first started by seeing if some franchises could lose some of their supplemental fighters. Mario and zfire Emblem (even in this thread Fire Emblem can’t escape) seemed to be an easy spot to lose fighters even though I’d like to keep Rosalina, Daisy, and Byleth. Next, I cut Sheik (a hard cut for me as I like playing as her) and Midna as there are other characters that I think are important. Greninja was cut from Pokemon as I though the other veterans were more important, and Tinkaton is an interesting choice for a new fighter, and she helps with gender representation. I thought of cutting third parties, and Tails, Master Chief, Snake, and Bomberman felt like the easiest cuts (I want to keep Tidus as I cut a few characters that I liked/want). Cutting down Xenoblade seemed like an easy choice, so Noah is gone. I also looked at franchises that could be easy cuts, and Arms, Duck Hunt, and unfortunately Golden Sun seemed like the easiest cuts. Finally, I made hard cuts with Tom Nook and Bandana Waddle Dee as I couldn’t think of other good choices for cutting.

 

[DragonRobotKing26]

The characters who i will cut are

1. Duck Hunt Duo
2. Chun-Li
3. Tails
4. Alucard
5. Lip
6. Octoling
7. Zero Suit Samus
8. Roy
9. Sheik
10. Falco
11. Palutena
12. Zoroark
13. Hatterene
14. Isabelle
15. Daisy
16. Terry
17. Min Min
18. Krystal
19. Midna
20. Isaac

 

[BritishGuy54]

Round 20:
[Paper Mario]

[Ring Fit]
(//Pneuma)[Noah]

[Lyn]
[Chun-Li][Dr. Eggman][Rayman]

Cuts: Zero, , , , , , Meowscarda, Shadow, Octoling, Rex, , , , Alear, , Impa, , Bandana Waddle Dee, ,

Spoiler: Reasons

The cuts are here. I had a hard time deciding who gets cut, especially at the end.

Zero was my weakest link. Five Capcom characters was always a tough sell. He was the easiest one to let go. Ken also got the axe due to Ryu and Chun-Li being better picks.

Bayonetta might be a controversial cut, but I think it may be possible anyway.

Falco was a bit of a filler slot, and Star Fox isn’t as active anymore. Same goes for Palutena for Kid Icarus.

Zelda being cut to just the Triforce Trio and Toon Link sucks, but it had to be done. Young Link and Impa aren’t enough to stay.

Meowscarda is a case of having to cut a Pokémon because I have to.

Sonic having three characters is a similar fluke like Street Fighter was. I decided to cut Shadow since Eggman was a bit more unique.

My opinion on Octoling is that I struggle to see how it can be implemented. I think it’s fine they get cut and possibly relegated to an alt for Inkling.

Four Xenoblade characters was always a hard sell. Rex is just the weakest link when Pythra are already present, and he more so reps 3’s DLC here.

Rosalina and Bowser Jr. are characters that had to happen. I would rather have Dr. Mario get cut, but I had to cut both. I’d rather keep Jr between the two, but keeping Eggman was enough to get the Koopa Prince out.

Dark Samus was tough, but between her and ZSS, I chose Dark Samus to leave.

Alear is a case of having to cut down on FE, but not too much.

Terry is one of the third parties gone, and he is the weakest link of the fighting game cast here.

BWD is such a fan favourite and highly requested. But over the other Kirby cast? No dice.

R.O.B. being cut is just having to cut down on retro faces.

The hardest pills to swallow here. Ness and Little Mac. Cutting an entire series out from Smash is difficult, but Mother ending on its own terms provides a better opportunity to move on from it compared to other series here, such as F-Zero. Punch-Out also is an easy choice to axe at this point.

 

[Pupp135]

Round 20:
[Paper Mario]

[Ring Fit]
(//Pneuma)[Noah]

[Lyn]
[Chun-Li][Dr. Eggman][Rayman]

Cuts: Zero, , , , , , Meowscarda, Shadow, Octoling, Rex, , , , Alear, , Impa, , Bandana Waddle Dee, ,

The cuts are here. I had a hard time deciding who gets cut, especially at the end.

Zero was my weakest link. Five Capcom characters was always a tough sell. He was the easiest one to let go. Ken also got the axe due to Ryu and Chun-Li being better picks.

Bayonetta might be a controversial cut, but I think it may be possible anyway.

Falco was a bit of a filler slot, and Star Fox isn’t as active anymore. Same goes for Palutena for Kid Icarus.

Zelda being cut to just the Triforce Trio sucks, but it had to be done. Toon Link, Young Link, and even Impa aren’t enough to stay.

Meowscarda is a case of having to cut a Pokémon because I have to.

Sonic having three characters is a similar fluke like Street Fighter was. I decided to cut Shadow since Eggman was a bit more unique.

My opinion on Octoling is that I struggle to see how it can be implemented. I think it’s fine they get cut and possible relegated to an alt for Inkling.

Four Xenoblade characters was always a hard sell. Rex is just the weakest link when Pythra are already present, and he more so reps 3’s DLC here.

Rosalina and Bowser Jr. are characters that had to happen. I would rather have Dr. Mario get cut, but I had to cut both. I’d rather keep Jr between the two, but keeping Eggman was enough to get the Koopa Prince out.

Dark Samus was tough, but between her and ZSS, I chose Dark Samus to leave.

Alear is a case of having to cut down on FE, but not too much.

Terry is one of the third parties gone, and he is the weakest link of the fighting game cast here.

BWD is such a fan favourite and highly requested. But over the other Kirby cast? No dice.

R.O.B. being cut is just having to cut down on retro faces.

The hardest pill to swallow here. Ness. Cutting an entire series out from Smash is difficult, but the series ending on its own terms provides a better opportunity to move on from it compared to other series here, such as Punch-Out, F-Zero, etc.

Because he was added to your round 19 roster, please replace Toon Link with another character to cut.

 

[BritishGuy54]

Because he was added to your round 19 roster, please replace Toon Link with another character to cut.

Update: Toon Link remains in. Little Mac is now out.

 

[ninjahmos]

(Geno)
(Waluigi)


(Karate Joe)
(Bill Rizer)
(Shadow)(Arle Nadja)
(Chun-Li)(Arthur)(Phoenix Wright)(Dante)
(Tidus)(Crash Bandicoot)(Travis Touchdown)(Rayman)
(Doom Slayer)(Ryu Hayabusa)

Cuts: , Dixie Kong, , , , , Quaxly, , , , , , Ring Fit Trainer, , NiGHTS, Kazuma Kiryu, , Lloyd Irving, Master Chief, Lara Croft

 

[BowserKing]

Fawful, Dixie Kong
Ashley, Midna, Mipha,
Dark Meta Knight, Susie, Krystal,
Sceptile, Glaceon, Boltund, Dragapult,

Tails, and Shantae

Daisy, King K.Rool, Ganondorf, Bandanna Dee, Wolf, Jigglypuff, Excadrill, Greninja, Tinkaton, Ness, Marth, Byleth, Mr.Game & Watch, R.O.B, Tom Nook, Amy, Knuckles, Zero, Cloud and Spider Jockey are all cut.

 

[Louie G.]

(Excitebiker)
(Tom Nook) (Off the Hook) (Chorus Kids)
(Lyn) () (Ring Fit)
(Solaire) (Arle) (Chun-Li) (Jill)

58/78

Spoiler: Explanation

Okay, so are automatically safe. That's fine with me.

My first course of action is to trim down the third parties. But I'm going to make the decision to commit to all of the new series that I've introduced so far (Puyo Puyo, Resident Evil, Dark Souls) and just worry about cutting down supplemental characters. Tails, Knuckles, Ken, Leon and Sephiroth get cut loose for now. I'm opting to keep Chun-Li, who I really just think stands on her own well enough and is usually treated as somewhat of a package deal with Ryu anyway.

It feels cheap to cut echo fighters, but we don't make the distinction here so they're fair game. Daisy, Lucina and Octoling are retired for the time being. Lucina hurts because she was here from the beginning, to give my roster a unique flair against the others. Now that has become a bit less important, and Robin is here, so Marth will take precedent. I'd like to bring her back on principle later, but we'll see what happens. I'm also concerned about the negative effect this has on my gender balance, something I've tried to be conscious of throughout this game, but I'll have time to make up for that later. I'm gonna lump Toon Link in with these guys because he's a variation on an existing character too.

I like to try and maintain as many original series on the roster as possible, so the next step is cutting down on some series that can afford to lose a supplemental character. Despite taking so long to build him back up, I'm going to cut Pokemon Trainer since that character takes up three unique slots. Most people would probably keep Charizard, but again I feel like he just isn't doing a whole lot on his own that other characters aren't doing better. Palutena and Wolf are unfortunate losses, two favorite characters of mine, but under dire circumstances these two series can stand with a single character. My eyes would wander toward Fire Emblem otherwise, but I like the four I have right now. No need to cut down any further.

I'm trying not to walk back on any of my newcomers, but there are a couple here I wasn't 1000% on. I'm going to cut Oatchi and Ogerpon, and give those series a bit more thought regarding how I'd like to expand on them. I may very well come back to these two but I'm less confident in them than some of my other choices. Four cuts left.

Unfortunately now I need to start cutting into series with only a single character. I'm losing Ice Climbers and ROB for now, simply because they have less mobility, and less potential for new content than some of the others. Out of the more "retro" oriented series, I'm going to hold onto Game & Watch because he's kind of the defacto surprise pick, and Little Mac because Punch-Out is greatly understated in its significance. He's closer to the likes of Ness, Captain Falcon and Pit than he is the Ice Climbers. Wii Fit Trainer I'm going to stubbornly keep around, because she's great. Min Min and Ring Fit Trainee can stay because they're from contemporary Nintendo IPs and we're low on those. On top of this I'm gonna cut uhhh... Mii Brawler. Will probably reinstate them later but they're not especially exciting on their own without the two other Mii options.

One cut left, and this one is just kinda going to have to be a crapshoot. Excitebiker kinda strides the line of what I was talking about before, although the "Excite" series is surprisingly substantial compared to some of the other retro picks. He's also pretty damn unique and again, I don't want to slink out on too many of my newcomer choices. Maybe a little redundant with Duck Hunt already here for now, but screw it. Incineroar would have been a sensible cut on paper, but that'd be going to skim on the Pokemon for now and I love having him around. K. Rool... eh... I'd just rather not. And all my remaining first party newcomers feel like great picks in my book.

I guess, for now, I'll cut Min Min. Mind you I'd rather she stay, but ARMS is just on the more expendable side of the represented series without dipping too much into some of the new stuff, and truthfully I see an outlet where I can add her again very soon if the future prompts are to be trusted. I didn't want to rely too hard on those but in an instance like this it's necessary to strategize a little. So I'll see you again soon, Min Min. At least I've still got some more contemporary characters hanging around like Off the Hook, Ring Fit Trainee and Pythra.

Cuts: (Ogerpon) (Oatchi) (Octoling) (Tails) (Knuckles) (Leon)

 

[nirvanafan]

(Gholdengo)(Diancie)(Arceus)(Gardevoir)
(King Rauru)(Ravio)
(Oatchi) (Dragaux)
(Nooklings)(KK Slider)(DJ Octavio)
(Alear)(Sami) (Ayumi)
(Shadow)(Eggman)(Tails)(Knuckles)
(Kiryu)(2B)(Chun Li)
(Crash)(Dingodile)(Master Chief)
(Lara Croft)(Hayabusa)

Cuts

1. Capt Toad
2. 
3. Genesect
4. Urshifu
5. 
6. Impa
7. Raven Beak
8. Krystal
9. Magalor
10. 
11. Big Man
12. Spring Man
13. 
14. /
15. Mio
16. Warrior of Light (FF14)
17. M. Bison
18. Shantae
19. Doom Slayer
20. Dingodile? (Think Aegis was 1 spot but if 2 he would stay)

 

[Pupp135]

(Gholdengo)(Diancie)(Arceus)(Gardevoir)
(King Rauru)(Ravio)
(Oatchi) (Dragaux)
(Nooklings)(KK Slider)(DJ Octavio)
(Alear)(Sami) (Ayumi)
(Shadow)(Eggman)(Tails)(Knuckles)
(Kiryu)(2B)(Chun Li)
(Crash)(Master Chief)(Lara Croft)(Hayabusa)

Cuts

1. Capt Toad
2. 
3. Genesect
4. Urshifu
5. 
6. Impa
7. Raven Beak
8. Krystal
9. Magalor
10. 
11. Big Man
12. Spring Man
13. 
14. /
15. Mio
16. Warrior of Light (FF14)
17. M. Bison
18. Shantae
19. Doom Slayer
20. Dingodile? (Think Aegis was 1 spot but if 2 he would stay)

Everyone counted Aegis differently, but I think you counted Aegis as two when you added them, so I’ll treat it like that, and Dingodile stays.

 

[Northsouthmap]

Because he was added to your round 19 roster, please replace Toon Link with another character to cut.

Actually he was added in round 5 like the original round post said

 

[Pupp135]

Actually he was added in round 5 like the original round post said

Thank you for the typo correction. It should’ve been round 19 in the description not 5.

 

[Otoad64]

Round 19:
(Captain Toad)(Waluigi)(Ashley)(Dixie Kong)(Cranky Kong)
(Impa)(Tingle)(Bandana Waddle Dee)
(Gengar)(Heracross)(Garchomp)(Zoroark)(Tinkaton)(Lyn)
(Oatchi)(Tom Nook)(/)(Callie & Marie)
(Chibi-Robo)(Dragaux)(Tails)(Shadow)(Zero)(Chun-Li)(Doom Slayer)(Red)

Additions: Cranky Kong, Wolf, Garchomp, Sephiroth, Red


Round 20:
(Captain Toad)(Waluigi)(Cranky Kong)(Impa)(Tingle)
(Bandana Waddle Dee)(Gengar)(Heracross)(Garchomp)(Lyn)
(Tom Nook)(Callie & Marie)(Chibi-Robo)(Doom Slayer)(Red)

Cuts:

1. Bowser Jr.
2. Ashley
3. Dixie Kong
4. Toon Link
5. Falco
6. Zoroark
7. Tinkaton
8. Lucas
9. Byleth
10. Palutena
11. Oatchi
12. Villager
13. Pyra
14. Mythra
15. Dragaux
16. Tails
17. Shadow
18. Snake
19. Zero
20. Chun-Li

 

[CrusherMania1592]

Anyone can join this? Or just certain people who has been playing for awhile now?

 

[darkvortex]

(Waluigi)
(Midna)
(Bandan Waddle Dee)(Meowscarada)
(Lyn) ( \ ) (Karate Joe)
(Ring Fit Adventurer)(Tom Nook) (Isaac) (Crash Bandicoot) (Master Chief) (Kratos) (Jill Valentine) (Rayman) (Terry)

1. Paper Mario
2. Dixie
3. Ashley
4. King Rauru
5. Raven Beak
6. Palutina
7. Meta Knight
8. Jigglypuff
9. Zoroark,
10. Marth
11. Otachi
12. Porky
13. Falco,
14. Villeger
15. Sami
16. Bayonetta
17. Dr. Eggman
18. Chun-Li
19. Sepihroth,
20. Alucard

 

[Pupp135]

Anyone can join this? Or just certain people who has been playing for awhile now?

Feel free to join the game. Because you joined late, and we have a round with 20 cuts (slightly more than a quarter of everyone’s rosters), I’ll have you need to create a roster of 57 fighters for this round. If you would like, you can also reserve 20 characters of your choice for the bonus round at the end of the game, which are the characters previously cut from other’s rosters. The next game that I plan on setting up will deal with recreating the series rosters.

 

[Pupp135]

Accidental double post

 

[CrusherMania1592]

Feel free to join the game. Because you joined late, and we have a round with 20 cuts (slightly more than a quarter of everyone’s rosters), I’ll have you need to create a roster of 57 fighters for this round. If you would like, you can also reserve 20 characters of your choice for the bonus round at the end of the game, which are the characters previously cut from other’s rosters. The next game that I plan on setting up will deal with recreating the series rosters.

Gotcha. I'll see if I did this right

(Meowscarada)(Vaati)(Crash Bandicoot)(Isaac)(Edelgard)(Ring Fit Trainer)(Dixie Kong)(Knuckles the Echnida)

I'll think of my adds soon

 

[Pupp135]

Gotcha. I'll see if I did this right

(Meowscarada)(Vaati)(Crash Bandicoot)(Isaac)(Edelgard)(Ring Fit Trainer)(Dixie Kong)(Knuckles the Echnida)

I'll think of my adds soon

It looks good to me.

Here are the roster’s

Pupp135

(/)
(Tinkaton)
(Octoling)(Ring Fit Trainee)
(Chun-Li)(Rayman)(Tidus)(Sans)

BritishGuy54
[Paper Mario]

[Ring Fit]
(//Pneuma)[Noah]

[Lyn]
[Chun-Li][Dr. Eggman][Rayman]

nirvanafan

(Gholdengo)(Diancie)(Arceus)(Gardevoir)
(King Rauru)(Ravio)
(Oatchi) (Dragaux)
(Nooklings)(KK Slider)(DJ Octavio)
(Alear)(Sami) (Ayumi)
(Shadow)(Eggman)(Tails)(Knuckles)
(Kiryu)(2B)(Chun Li)
(Crash)(Dingodile)(Master Chief)(Lara Croft)(Hayabusa)

BowserKing
Fawful, Dixie Kong
Ashley, Midna, Mipha,
Dark Meta Knight, Susie, Krystal,
Sceptile, Glaceon, Boltund, Dragapult,

Tails, and Shantae

Otoad64


(Captain Toad)(Waluigi)(Cranky Kong)(Impa)(Tingle)
(Bandana Waddle Dee)(Gengar)(Heracross)(Garchomp)(Lyn)
(Tom Nook)(Callie & Marie)(Chibi-Robo)(Doom Slayer)(Red)

darkvortex
(Waluigi)
(Midna)
(Bandan Waddle Dee)(Meowscarada)
(Lyn) ( \ ) (Karate Joe)
(Ring Fit Adventurer)(Tom Nook) (Isaac) (Crash Bandicoot) (Master Chief) (Kratos) (Jill Valentine) (Rayman) (Terry)

DragonRobotKing26
(King Boo) (Ashley)
Dixie Kong(Bandana Waddle Dee)(Adeline & Ribbon)
(Heracross)(Gardevoir)(Meowscarada)
(DJ Octavio)(Porky Minch)(Rex)
(Bomberman)(Arle)(Rayman)(Master Chief)

Louie G.

(Excitebiker)
(Tom Nook) (Off the Hook) (Chorus Kids)
(Lyn) () (Ring Fit)
(Solaire) (Arle) (Chun-Li) (Jill)

ninjahmos
(Geno)
(Waluigi)


(Karate Joe)
(Bill Rizer)
(Shadow)(Arle Nadja)
(Chun-Li)(Arthur)(Phoenix Wright)(Dante)
(Tidus)(Crash Bandicoot)(Travis Touchdown)(Rayman)
(Doom Slayer)(Ryu Hayabusa)

CrusherMania1592
(Meowscarada)(Vaati)(Crash Bandicoot)(Isaac)(Edelgard)(Ring Fit Trainer)(Dixie Kong)(Knuckles the Echnida)

Vote for your three favorite rosters, where yours is not first.

1. CrusherMania1592
2. Louie G.
3. Darkvortex

Spoiler: Upcoming Rounds

Pick one character for each subtractive primary color (cyan, magenta, yellow)
Add three characters to a franchise
Add three third party fighters
Add four Nintendo fighters
Final Round: Add five fighters of your choice
Bonus Round: Cut characters return

For upcoming rounds, cut characters are not allowed, so here is the barred list for each player.

Spoiler: Barred Fighters

Pupp135: Rosalina, Bowser Jr., Daisy, King K. Rool, Sheik, Midna, Bandana Waddle Dee, Greninja, Byleth, Lucina, Veyle, Tom Nook, Noah, Min Min, Duck Hunt, Isaac, Bomberman, Snake, Tails, Master Chief
BritishGuy54: Rosalina, Bowser Jr., Young Link, Impa, Dark Samus, Bandana Waddle Dee, Falco, Ness, Alear, Palutena, Rex, Octoling, R.O.B., Little Mac, Zero, Ken, Shadow, Terry Bogard, Bayonetta
Nirvanafan: Luigi, Captain Toad, Ganondorf, Impa, Raven Beak, Magalor, Krystal, Genesect, Urshifu, Robin, Isabelle, Aegis, Mio, Big Man, Spring Man, M. Bison, Doom Slayer, Warrior of Light (FFXIV), Shantae
BowserKing: Daisy, King K. Rool, Ganondorf, Bandana Waddle Dee, Wolf, Jigglypuff, Excadrill, Greninja, Tinkaton, Ness, Marth, Byleth, Tom Nook, Mr. Game & Watch, R.O.B., Amy, Knuckles, Zero, Cloud, Spider Jockey
OToad64: Bowser Jr., Dixie Kong, Toon Link, Falco, Zoroark, Tinkaton, Lucas, Byleth, Palutena, Ashley, Oatchi, Villager, Aegis, Dragaux, Zero, Snake, Chun-Li, Tails, Shadow
Darkvortex: Paper Mario, Dixie Kong, King Rauru, Raven Beak, Meta Knight, Falco, Jigglypuff, Zoroark, Porky, Marth, Palutena, Ashley, Oatchi, Villager, Sami, Chun-Li, Alucard, Dr. Eggman, Sephiroth, Bayonetta
DragonRobotKing26: Daisy, Sheik, Midna, Zero Suit Samus, Falco, Krystal, Zoroark, Hatterne, Roy, Palutena, Isabelle, Octoling, Min Min, Duck Hunt, Lip, Isaac, Chun-Li, Alucard, Tails, Terry Bogard,
Louie G: Daisy, Toon Link, Wolf, Pokemon Trainer, Ogerpon, Lucina, Palutena, Oatchi, Octoling, Min Min, Ice Climbers, R.O.B., Mii Brawler, Ken, Tails, Knuckles, Leon, Sephiroth
Ninjahmos: Bowser Jr., Dixie Kong, Sheik, Falco, Jigglypuff, Pokemon Trainer, Quaxly, Lucas, Lucina, Roy, Min Min, Duck Hunt, Ring Fit Trainee, Ken, Simon Belmont, NiGHTS, Lara Croft, Kazuma Kiryu, Master Chief, Lloyd Irving
CrusherMania:

 

[BritishGuy54]

1. CrusherMania
2. Myself
3. Louie G.

 

[nirvanafan]

CrusherMania1592
Pupp135
Myself

 

[BowserKing]

1.OToad64
2.Mine
3.Louie G

 

[DragonRobotKing26]

1. CrusherMania
2. Otoaf64
3. Louie G.

 

[ninjahmos]

1. CrusherMania1592
2. Myself
3. Louie G.

 

[Louie G.]

1. Pupp
2. Mine
3. CrusherMania

Special mention to darkvortex, I like the spread of single-rep first party franchises but couldn't really get past the exclusion of Meta Knight.

And welcome to the game, Crusher!

For upcoming rounds, cut characters are not allowed, so here is the barred list for each player.

This definitely threw a wrench in my future plans, which is frustrating but I have to commend you for keeping things fresh with some of these surprise limitations even while telling us the future rounds. Good compromise between transparency but also forcing us to think on the spot and come up with some creative solutions. Although I'll certainly miss a few having a few of them on my roster in particular.

 

[darkvortex]

1. Crusher
2. Pupp
3. Louie

Had I known they'd stay gone I likey wouldn't have cut Meta Knight

 

[CrusherMania1592]

1. BritishGuy
2. Myself
3. Pupp

Thanks for the inclusion to this

 

[Otoad64]

1. Louie G.
2. Mine
3. Pupp135

 

[Pupp135]

Here are the votes

Pupp135 9
BritishGuy54 5
nirvanafan 1
BowserKing 2
Otoad64 7
darkvortex 1
DragonRobotKing26
Louie G. 12
ninjahmos 2
CrusherMania1592 21

CrusherMania1592 wins this round, Louie G. gets second, and I get third. Crushermania1592 gets five points, Louie G. gets three, and I get 1.

Spoiler: Leaderboard

1. Louie G. 80
2. OToad64 31
3. Pupp135 25
4. Northsouthmap 21
5. Darkvorex 16
6. Nirvanafan 8
7. DragonRobotKing 6
8. CrusherMania1592 5
9. BritishGuy54, BowserKing 3
11. Ninjahmos

Round 21: Add a character who represents each subtractive primary color (cyan (turquoise or sky blue work), magenta (pink or purple works here), and yellow).

(/)
(Tinkaton)
(Octoling)(Oatchi)(Ring Fit Trainee)
(Amy Rose)(Chun-Li)(Rayman)(Tidus)(Sans)

This round was a pretty complicated one when trying to think of a choice for cyan or yellow, and then I remembered that Wii Fit Trainer has a cyan shirt as her default shirt color. For magenta, Amy is admittedly an indulgent pick, but I can always add Mewtwo or Waluigi later. For yellow, I went with Oatchi as Pikmin 4 is a fresh game.

Spoiler: Upcoming Rounds

Add three characters to a franchise
Add three third party fighters
Add four Nintendo fighters
Final Round: Add five fighters of your choice
Bonus Round: Cut characters return

For upcoming rounds, cut characters are not allowed, so here is the barred list for each player.

Spoiler: Barred Fighters

Pupp135: Rosalina, Bowser Jr., Daisy, King K. Rool, Sheik, Midna, Bandana Waddle Dee, Greninja, Byleth, Lucina, Veyle, Tom Nook, Noah, Min Min, Duck Hunt, Isaac, Bomberman, Snake, Tails, Master Chief
BritishGuy54: Rosalina, Bowser Jr., Young Link, Impa, Dark Samus, Bandana Waddle Dee, Falco, Ness, Alear, Palutena, Rex, Octoling, R.O.B., Little Mac, Zero, Ken, Shadow, Terry Bogard, Bayonetta
Nirvanafan: Luigi, Captain Toad, Ganondorf, Impa, Raven Beak, Magalor, Krystal, Genesect, Urshifu, Robin, Isabelle, Aegis, Mio, Big Man, Spring Man, M. Bison, Doom Slayer, Warrior of Light (FFXIV), Shantae
BowserKing: Daisy, King K. Rool, Ganondorf, Bandana Waddle Dee, Wolf, Jigglypuff, Excadrill, Greninja, Tinkaton, Ness, Marth, Byleth, Tom Nook, Mr. Game & Watch, R.O.B., Amy, Knuckles, Zero, Cloud, Spider Jockey
OToad64: Bowser Jr., Dixie Kong, Toon Link, Falco, Zoroark, Tinkaton, Lucas, Byleth, Palutena, Ashley, Oatchi, Villager, Aegis, Dragaux, Zero, Snake, Chun-Li, Tails, Shadow
Darkvortex: Paper Mario, Dixie Kong, King Rauru, Raven Beak, Meta Knight, Falco, Jigglypuff, Zoroark, Porky, Marth, Palutena, Ashley, Oatchi, Villager, Sami, Chun-Li, Alucard, Dr. Eggman, Sephiroth, Bayonetta
DragonRobotKing26: Daisy, Sheik, Midna, Zero Suit Samus, Falco, Krystal, Zoroark, Hatterne, Roy, Palutena, Isabelle, Octoling, Min Min, Duck Hunt, Lip, Isaac, Chun-Li, Alucard, Tails, Terry Bogard,
Louie G: Daisy, Toon Link, Wolf, Pokemon Trainer, Ogerpon, Lucina, Palutena, Oatchi, Octoling, Min Min, Ice Climbers, R.O.B., Mii Brawler, Ken, Tails, Knuckles, Leon, Sephiroth
Ninjahmos: Bowser Jr., Dixie Kong, Sheik, Falco, Jigglypuff, Pokemon Trainer, Quaxly, Lucas, Lucina, Roy, Min Min, Duck Hunt, Ring Fit Trainee, Ken, Simon Belmont, NiGHTS, Lara Croft, Kazuma Kiryu, Master Chief, Lloyd Irving
CrusherMania:

 

[BritishGuy54]

Round 21:
[Paper Mario]
[Funky Kong]

(//Pneuma)[Noah][Ring Fit]

[Lyn]
[Chun-Li][Dr. Eggman]
[Rayman]

Additions: Mii Gunner (Yellow), Jigglypuff (Magenta), Funky Kong (Cyan)

Mii Gunner was an easy follow-up to Mii Brawler.

Jigglypuff is the weakest link of the original 12, but I think if this roster is this big, Puff can return.

Funky Kong is a curveball pick, and essentially a DK echo. But I think DK has earned its third rep, even if it isn’t K. Rool.

(Also one of my barred fighters is Meowscarda, but it isn’t listed for some reason)

 

[nirvanafan]

(Liked how clean CrusherMania1592's roster looked so reorganized mine)





(King Rauru)(Ravio)(Sami)(Ayumi)(Alear)
(Gholdengo)(Diancie)(Arceus)(Gardevoir)
(Nooklings)(KK Slider)(Oatchi)(DJ Octavio)
(Dragaux)(Shadow)(Eggman)(Tails)(Knuckles)
(Kiryu)(Nights)(2B)(Chun Li)(Kos-Mos)
(Crash)(Dingodile)(Master Chief)(Lara Croft)
(Hayabusa)

Newcomers:

Cyan: Kos-Mos
Magenta: Nights
Yellow: