If you're saying Alina is an all-around better player than Brenda then why is Brenda in such a stronger position than Alina at the moment?
You act as if Brenda's only good move was when she decided to split the votes. She's made almost all of the right choices in terms of alliances. She rallied an alliance against the biggest leader of La Flor... IN THEIR FIRST TRIBAL! A huge move that has never been seen so early in a Survivor season. She has even shown that she has great potential in challenges... Remember that once challenge where everyone was blindfolded and someone had to be a caller? Guess who the caller was? You guessed it. Brenda. I don't see Alina helping as much in challenges. Also don't forget Brenda has been the main one responsible for taking out 2 out of 4 people in Alina's main alliance (Shannon, Kelly B., Jud, and Alina).
I'm completely unbiased and a true Survivor fan. So far the biggest player this season has been Brenda (with Marty close behind). Anyone who denies that is delusional.
I'm not sure who you were talking to right there, but... I have to agree somewhat with Livewire. Brenda is definitely getting a really positive edit. I'll say again that I was really impressed with what she did at Tribal this last episode, but it's certainly not true that moves of that magnitude hasn't been done before. One of mt favorite Survivors ever has to be Chris from Vanuatu. Of course there is some luck involved, and while he didn't do too much but side with the majority at the very beginning to save his own ***, he played extremely smart early game to eventually come out on top. Brenda is just doing it in a season where everyone on her tribe is being edited like Brett from Samoa. I don't think we've even seen anyone else from La Flor for half the amount of time we've seen Na'Onka, Brenda, and Jud. It's just how they're editing it. Because I like to view seasons by edits and edits by profit, I think this:
CBS sees that Brenda is like Parvati. She's beautiful, cunning, and sneaky (also, the only really interesting Asian female we've had on Survivor (sorry, Shii-Ann)), but unfortunately something happens and she doesn't win, like with Russell. They edit her to look even better than she is actually doing so fans fall in love with her and they can bring her back for another season in the future. Just like Russell.
I'd certainly argue that Marty's a bigger player than Brenda. And making big, obvious and out there moves does not always equate to you being the best player. I think that should be obvious to any fan by now. We haven't seen Alina have much of an opportunity to have to make any big moves yet, and she's been able to stay out of trouble on New Espada, when Chase/Naonka could've gone with the old folks to get her and Benry out. Brenda's over the top edit about things and how her moves are trying to be shown just screams overblown and exaggerated to me. I say this not as a biased person, but as a relatively unbiased one. I mean yes, I get it, Brenda's a villain, and so is Naonka. And I understand that rooting for the underdogs in this situation that would be Marty and Alina makes it seem like I'm just biased-ly voting for 'good' over 'evil' (though mind you, Fairplay is one of my favourites and he was clearly evil). However, with having my 3 favourites as Fabio, Marty, and Alina, with Jane possibly being there if she wakes up and realizes she's expendable to Brenda, I can't help but keep a bit to my picks. Nobody's totally unbiased.
See above for opinion on Brenda. And, I agree with Marty being a bigger player. But that does partially go to the fact he's had five tribal council's to shine, and she's only had two...
Marty is the biggest player, but not the best. A lot of the stuff he did like voting off the Jimmys was a terrible idea and really short sighted.
I don't think it was a flaw in voting off the Jimmy's. If Jimmy Johnson found any reason to get rid of Marty (if everyone else was sick of him and he didn't want to be on their bad side), he would do it. And people didn't like Marty too much. Same with Jimmy T. No one wanted Jimmy T. around still. He was as bad as Wendy. When you read Jeff and Dalton's blogs, you can tell where the contestants just got sick of him. They were both fairly solid moves. Tyrone was A-Okay before the Jimmy's were voted, so unless you can think of better moves (besides getting rid of Dan, which as much as I love him and his adorable puppy dog eyes, I know should of happened by now), I'm calling my point valid. x: