Mk is bad but not that bad imo. Ganon punishes too hard and outranges in lots of cases, but i wont get into that argument now, marth is similar to MK.
Snake is not that bad either imo, but again, i would prolly not argue that now.
ICs get dtilt *****, but its still bad iunno.
I know hes bottom tier, i dont think hes underrated at all actually, I just think he really makes matchups wierd cuz at super high levels he gets a little worse because a lot of his game (most of it actually) is capitilizing on mistakes reaaally hard, and lots of times, it depends on whether you get that one gerudos, or read that one MK ftilt, that decides the outcome.
Of course you guys discussed the matchups, I just think that you are very wrong (the ratios, not you in particular)XD
Socks, not to come down on you TOO hard, but there's a reason Ganon is a bottom-tier character. I actually intend to make a topic about this, including why characters like MK are so high because of design flaws, but that's another matter. The reason Ganondorf is a bottom tier character is fourfold. The first is, he has no projectile. This immediately renders him on the offensive, which, in Brawl, is a place you do not want to be. The second is that, being on the offensive, his approach game is, frankly, rather crappy, what with his low speed, short jumps, lack of mobile moves that do not lag, and his size. The third is, of course, his massive, massive lag, and the fact that even when he gets in range, they are easily blocked, easily dodged, only hit once, and do not do enough damage in order to set up guaranteed (or even easy) kills. The fourth and most obvious is, of course, his recovery. Ganon gets gimped. Period. There is not a character in the game who does not get gimped worse than Ganon (other than Link, but even he's got defensive advantages).
MK ***** Ganon because MKs never stop attacking long enough for Ganon to get a hit in edgewise, outrange and outprioritize almost everything Ganon can do, knock Ganon off the stage easily thanks to their overpowered attack angles, and are, of course, the best gimpers in the game.
Similar to MK, Marth ***** Ganon because of his disjointed hitbox, range, aerial defensive game, and gimping.
As for Snake, the reason Snake ***** Ganon is because everything Ganon SHOULD have, Snake has, and better. Power? Snake's utilt/ftilt. Projectiles? Oh, the traps and tricks one can do with nades. Lag? Utilt/ftilt. Recovery? Don't even try to deny it.
As for the ICs, they are rather different than all of the above examples. The reason they **** Ganon is because of an unfortunate confluence of circumstances, such as the ones that render a game between a DK and a DDD unwinnable for the DK. In other words, there is nothing Ganon can do that won't get him grabbed, and once he's grabbed, he dies.
