I voted
1st: Mic_128
Not only does he keep a lot of the more difficult rooms spotless, he also gave me my first warning!!!
2nd: Evil Eye
Would've been my choice but he's never warned me. Good writer; poster. He has developed some great tournament ideas in the past, although toucan play at that game!
3rd: Crimson King
My hatred for CK was passionate and fiery when I was first let into the Debate Hall, since he practically accused me of plagiarizing and then insulted my grammar. Then I realized that this is the internet. He did a lot with the Debate Hall and is generally relaxed.
I think Crimson King's name has more to do with King Crimson than any magazine, by the way.
EDIT: Don't post if you know I'm posting, Sporkman. >:|