Bingo Mafia: OVAH! Who won?

[DtJ Glyphmoney]

RVS? whats that?

Random Vote Stage. Pretty much you throw votes around until something interesting happens are roll from there.

Though right now it looks like we'll just be lynching scumJ and skipping that.

 

[#HBC | J]

Awwww I'm getting lynched again....

Can I at least pretend a little longer?

 

[JTB]

Doesn't matter, Larry Butz is hopeless anyways

NBD

 

[#HBC | J]

What's the matter with you!? Larry Butz is awesome and haters are just gonna hate on him!

Btw what does NBD mean?

 

[smargaret]

RVS? whats that?

Hey Kuz, is Aposl scum?

Aposl, go read. RVS is an icebreaker at the beginning of the game where you vote for random reasons like disliking someone's avatar or something.

 

[JTB]

What's the matter with you!? Larry Butz is awesome and haters are just gonna hate on him!

Btw what does NBD mean?

NO BiG DEAL

 

[#HBC | J]

;___;

No one loves Larry or J.

 

[th3kuzinator]

Hey Kuz, is Aposl scum?

Aposl, go read. RVS is an icebreaker at the beginning of the game where you vote for random reasons like disliking someone's avatar or something.

No.

10char

 

[Aposl]

Does this actually progress the game, I feel like the best first round vote is to vote out the least intelligent player, my reasoning is as follows, even if hes on your team he can hurt it, so you dont feel as bad when he turns out to be town. But you will feel bad if you vote out a decent player, and it turns out that he is on your side. Same goes for Mafia's team. If the dumbest player is town this is free to you, if hes in your team, you could use it as a strategy to mind game the opponent. This strategy requires no random vote, just lynch the village idiot.

 

[JTB]

We lynching Soupamario d1? k

 

[DtJ Glyphmoney]

That sounds great in concept, but how do you define the least intelligent? The least experienced? The worst record?

There's a lot more to a lynch than just removing a player, you also have to look at the connections they've established and use them to help make future decisions.

 

[KevinM]

Does this actually progress the game, I feel like the best first round vote is to vote out the least intelligent player, my reasoning is as follows, even if hes on your team he can hurt it, so you dont feel as bad when he turns out to be town. But you will feel bad if you vote out a decent player, and it turns out that he is on your side. Same goes for Mafia's team. If the dumbest player is town this is free to you, if hes in your team, you could use it as a strategy to mind game the opponent. This strategy requires no random vote, just lynch the village idiot.

I like this guy.

Lynch the worst townie players win in Lylo!

 

[th3kuzinator]

Does this actually progress the game, I feel like the best first round vote is to vote out the least intelligent player, my reasoning is as follows, even if hes on your team he can hurt it, so you dont feel as bad when he turns out to be town.

Does what progress the game?

 

[Asdioh]

I hoped I wouldn't have to say this, but I realllllly hope the pregame chatter crap is kept to an absolute minimum. I'm going to try to post no more until the game actually starts.

*looks at J*

 

[Aposl]

Well let me rephrase. Not least intelligent, but least logical. Yes there is experienced players who can probably read the hell out of noobs, but the noobiest thing a person can do is make incorrect logical connections. Basically people who's thinking style is weak. We still have to do the same thing in this "stage" of the game, but if we go after people's intelligence instead of alliance it will allow us to see everyones defense style, argumentation style etc... See how they think, judge whose thinking is the weakest and rid ourselves of them. I have lost a Mafia game because someone on my team couldn't make the correct logical connections to players actions, and game situations, where if I had been in his role it would have been GG's.

Also we can still accuse people of being Mafia, or town or whatever but still implement this strategy.

 

[Aposl]

Does what progress the game?

I was referring to random accusations, or seemingly random accusations. When I play I am pretty straight forward, and give a complete breakdown of my reasoning for my POV's.

 

[JTB]

Accusations force reactions out of people, which can help determine alignments.

 

[th3kuzinator]

Just telling you now, if your strategy involves bypassing a lynch off of scumhunting just to lynch the dumbest player, it will not be implemented.

Random accusation stages dont mean much in the long run, just something to stimulate conversation. So yes, they do progress the game as they help bring up stances that can be referenced later.

 

[Aposl]

Accusations force reactions out of people, which can help determine alignments.

Now this is what I was referring too. This may be true, but you state it as an absolute. Reactions can be simulated, or people can lie, or not react (which some will take as a reactions.)But in the end I feel it much better to force, convince or trick people into telling their opinions about something without being defensive.

I guess I will be the good cop and you accusers can be the bad cop. Lol

 

[th3kuzinator]

@X1, J, Asdioh: Analysis of this post.

 

[smargaret]

Reference to DnD mafia. Hence directed at Kuz. You, of all people, should have gotten that.

Now, however, Aposl's done something legitimately scummy in proposing a policy lynch without even having a target. I don't know how you play IRL mafia, but when I do it, it's a lot more joking in the sense of AIMafia and nobody would even think of policy lynching. I'm getting hints of lies about experience (would someone know enough about forum mafia in their first game to know what a policy lynch looks like? doesn't sound right with earlier questions about RVS) and frankly, PLing is anti-town in general. Since the suggestion was apparently in earnest, I'm now officially suspicious of Aposl.

 

[JTB]

Whose hydra is Pink Lemonade?

 

[Pink Lemonade]

Ranmaru/July/Joey

Drink us. Confirm.

 

[Pink Lemonade]

I'm really excited for this game to start. =D

Hey it's Larry Butz!

If something smells, it's usually the butz.

 

[Pink Lemonade]

Doom taught me, I played at Pound5 3 times with Esam, GIMR (my brother), Xaltis, MVD. Chibo, Seibrik, etc... Doom regulated it. It was good times!

ARGH WHy didn't Chibo tell me i was there lol. Imma get Chibo.

 

[JTB]

Location: Ran/July/Joey

Ran/July/Joey

Ran

l

 

[BSL]

Confirming.

Sqweedle is soup? I've been bamboozled!!

 

[Kataefi]

Sqweedle is the only player left to confirm! Let's cyber bully him into confirming so we can start

 

[DtJ Glyphmoney]

Screw that, if we can find out where he lives we can really get 'im good.

 

[JTB]

Screw that, if we can find out where he lives we can really get 'im good.

 

[X1-12]

Lynch Smar

Lynch J

Lynch Glyph

tentative on the last two.

Good catch on that post kuz.

 

[X1-12]

@kuz: #61 is more telling than the one you pulled up, but its down to you so still good stuff.


Is this the game with Seikend in?

@Seikend: Do you agree with me that Smar is scum?

If he's not in this game, then anyone who's not playing in (or played in) DKR but is fairly new can answer

 

[X1-12]

checked, Seikend is in this game and is viewing.


Answer me ASAP please.

 

[Seikend]

I'm not playing the game before everyone is confirmed.

Once sqweedle confirms I'll tell you what I think.

 

[X1-12]

I'm not playing the game before everyone is confirmed.

Once sqweedle confirms I'll tell you what I think.

oh not this again. You know your aligment as does smar. Waiting is a waste of time and anti town and makes me think your waiting for a scumbud to tell you what to say

 

[JTB]

What difference would it make if you told us now?

 

[JTB]

EBWOP

Basically what X1 said. Also, it's not like sqweedle has to sift through hundreds of posts when the game starts, we haven't even broke into the third page yet.

 

[Seikend]

Fine, I'll answer the question. I just don't want discussion happening. Kinda defeats the point of having to confirm.

No, smar doesn't look scummy. Having read DnD Mafia before, the reference makes sense. Not sure how I feel about her suspicion of Aposl.

There's not been anything significant enough to say that smar is scum yet.

 

[JTB]

The point of having everyone confirm is to make sure everyone is ready when we can start voting, not to make sure everyone is ready for discussion.

Atleast that's what I've taken from other games.

I SEE YOU THERE SOUPA, CONFIRM DAMMIT

 

[Sqweedle]

/confirm

D1 Plans:

Tunnel J
Fluff repeadtly
enjoy coffee
post objection alot.

k gogogogo