this post is dumb for so many reasons. the main reason however is saying brawl is better then melee. Your complants about 0-deaths i find confusing. Since when in a competitive game do we complain about another players skill...? 0-deaths weren't a cheap one button combo (toon links dsmash...) 0-deaths required a certain skill and preciseness. Not to mention it also took a certain skill to avoid them.
next the technical aspects of melee only allowed the game more options. in brawl you are restricted to the same ways of approach every time, which promotes camping. this makes game play boring and repetitive. you should be terrible in melee if your not technical because you arent using the maximum amount options available to attack your opponent. Not to mention i hope ur not one of those idiots who thinks the technical players lacked mindgames. in fact those players probably had the most because they had to calculate multiple steps ahead of time faster then the slower players.
third however mindgames are clearly more prevalent in brawl it is harder to apply them. in melee a player who lacked mindgames could easily be predicted and punished. in brawl you may predict your opponent but after hitting them once you must wait again for another moment to hit them because what... ... ... ?? theres no hit stun aka no combos so i can't hit him twice without him just hitting me first. mindgames = still there but it takes alot longer because after every hit i gotta stop and start control over again.
i believe the lack of hit stun is the biggest downfall in brawl because it allows nubs who mash buttons inbetween hits to ruin the skill of other players. not to mention some people can just spam their attacks and have no lag ever (Metadouche). oh and i almost forgot the fuucking dumb cross stage infinite chain grabs >_>
but honestly clearly brawl is better
Sir you make good points.. but i must tell you...
Yes; clearly it requires skill to perform a 0-death chaingrab on FD w/ Marth on Fox/Falco [you live in NJ so i know you've seen M2K], or watch Doll/Wife Uthrow-->Death w/ Peach.
I never said that it does not take skill inorder to DO combos in brawl.. but near the end melee seemed to me much like a mortal combat knockoff, and because of this you were seeing VERY NEW players do well in the tournament scene [and trust me my good sir.. my scene is greatly skilled.. i live in Md/Va] b/c of an excess of technical skill. Experience should be a large factor in any game.. but at the same time ALOT of melee players used tech skill as a crutch to keep up w/ the pros.
Look at Azen. He was/is so good that he can simply win a game [even against pros] by spamming Marth's Fsmash. That is how the game was meant to be played... to trick your opponent or read them so well that you are able to predict exactly where they are going... instead of "reacting" to your opponents **** UPS and WDing back and dong a shine combo. Forward is another extremely excellent example.. He beat ShizWiz @ Inn5 in WestMemphis even though Shiz's Falco is extremely technical [*pound* to all FL smashers.. yall win @ life].. why did this occur.. b/c Shiz was out mindgamed by experience.. not outplayed by a player more technical than him.
Even pros make mistakes my good sir.. so if a random nub is getting smashed by Azen from 0-80 and then the nublet hits Azen once and is able to 0-death him... does that mean the non pro/lacking in 1337ness player is superior to Azen??? **** NO. Now look at Mango.. overly technical... only w/ rest. Other than that.. MINDGAMES.
It means the game was completely imbalanced and basically [near the end] a total of 3 tournament viable characters that stood in concession to win were seen... Fox/Shiek/Marth..
Falcos were often gimped by the Marth's and Shieks.. and though Peach is quite good against Falcon/Falco, her game against a skilled Shiek/Marth/Fox is too much for her turnip spamming hands to handle. Melee was repetitive. Melee was dying. Who honestly wants to play a game that [if you want any chance to win money] causes you to conform to 1 of 3 characters. This isn't street fighter.. its SSB.
Lack of technical skill johns for lack of mindgames DO NOT IMPRESS ME.
Play Snake or Wolf if you want to add some tech skill to a game that [supposedly] rewards camping..
BTW.. do you know how to stop a camper...
STOP CAMPING THEM YOURSELF AND GET IN THEIR FCUKING FACE!
THEY CANT SPAM **** AT YOU IF YOUR FRICKING NEXT TO THEM.
Good Day Sirs.