Okay. Initial read-through: OS needs to die, obv. :S
Like what Omni pointed out, I have no idea how that initial case got started, but it's really just the events that followed. I mean... just to add to the pot: the entire day phase his reason for no defense was 'I don't want to manipulate town' (which is hard for me to believe anyways). And then he starts going on about how he wants Vig to shoot him (manipulating town...), and then how he doesn't want Vig to shoot him (manipulating town... + confusion). Then there's mostly anything else that's been mentioned. Even on the off chance he's town, his play is nothing but trouble and needs to die anyways.
Easy way to jump aboard the OS wagon with ease. Gave the basic "Overswarm needs to die no matter what", reasoning.
To put it simply, do you feel you can trust OS at all? I mean, you should be cautious of everyone and all, but everything Overswarm says makes me think he's trying to trick us, or is leaving something out, or maybe just trying to confuse everyone. Heck, I think he wants us to think he's trying to trick us, it seems so deliberate. And if he's town why is he trying to do that? Other than to get kicks and giggles. It doesn't make sense, and unless we were Overswarm we can barely guess what Overswarm is Overswarming.
Also, or perhaps because of that, the discussion topic is going to keep going to Overswarm while Overswarm lives.. He's always going to be suspicious, and it's not like you can ignore it.
It's even hard to explain =/
Poorly written post. Just lists out every possibility and bundles them as a reason for why OS should die. Didn't really take a specific stance on the lynch, but tried to find a way to take
every stance, lol.
I like how OS can make me feel he's town by saying "I'm town."
@MK- How did you/do you feel about OS, alignment wise?
Breadcrumbing that he thinks OS is town for later? This is after OS is
going to die. This was vague enough to not be that important, but it's something that stuck out to me
Next S2 makes a case on Meta Kirby, which I actually thought was sound. And a lot of his points on him do have good foundation.
^Zen sums it up really nicely. Also I thought he was at L-1.
I'm sorry for those that disagree with my first 3 posts. If it makes it up to everyone, I'll make a case on someone else as soon as OS flips. But seriously he needs to die.
Says that he'll make a case on a player (ends up being MK) as soon as OS flips. Which usually isn't a big deal. Except he didn't put forth any effort to jump onto the OS wagon, he just gave an "oh cool yeah I'll join" and hopped aboard. Gave him a clean ride through D1.
@MK- I read your defense and I just have one problem.
I can understand if you saw it this way and that's fine and all.
But... if that was the case. What kind of response is this?
So out of MK's whole rebuttal, he found
one thing he didn't like. He basically dropped the case with this, wanting MK to "answer his question", slowly moving from the case because it mostly likely wasn't going to go anywhere. But he still held onto it slightly, so that he would have something to fall back on, and look like he was doing stuff.
Pokemon White ate my life, sorry.
Technically if you combine me and Vult Redux's posts, it's 20. Agreed about the inactive hunting though lol. To be fair, I've been kinda productive with what I do, and I don't spread what should be 1 post over 3 like what some people do...
Is this from yourself, or from your "source"? Also, have you considered that your source may be scum?
Vote TigerWoods
On top of Nich's points, I don't like like the excessive cautiousness. Sure, you do things that I don't think most scum would do (unless they're about to get lynched and have nothing to lose, like yourself), but you also foreshadow it and I think you're trying to gauge what kind of reaction you'll get beforehand.
I'm happy with TW if that's what we're going to, but if not I want to go back to MK. His defense answered my points and all, but doesn't make them less true, only brought up a possibility. And he still hasn't addressed #510 :@. Also when did he vote Rockin?
He says that MK's defenses answered his points, but didn't prove his points wrong. Well, if that's the case, why remove the vote? Why back off? Especially considering he didn't say anything that made his points "less true".
This is also the post he jumps on the Tiger Wagon. Notice that he lists MK as his backup that he would go after if TW isn't the play. But at this point TW
will be the play. Also note that up until now he hasn't said a word about Jungle, other than asking Zen why he wants me lynched over him, TW, and MK. This is what bothered me most of all.
Vote: Sold2
Metakirby can wait. I like Nich's "Tiger was trying to cover his tracks and was scrambling" case.
This also really bothered me. Like I said above, the case wasn't going to go anywhere, and he moves from it with an UNVOTE. Not a vote for someone else. And his reasoning? MK can wait. What can he wait for? It's not If he had put his vote on someone else at this time it wouldn't have been as big of a deal. He removed what pressure he had on MK, and the fact that he said that he "can wait", implies that he still wants him to die, just not that he doesn't have to now. I don't buy it. He backed down because his case failed.
)
