There's all kinds of weird factors in the list. for example, i originally had candy at #1 because i felt he was playing the best brawl out of anyone recently, but omni always beats candy and usually places higher. however, omni goes to a tourney once a month at best, and gets annihilated by good OOSers/. so its hard to make a decision. then theres meeeeeeeep, who ***** people now with ICs and wins tourneys splits matches with candy and does similarly to candy, won a tourney recently, but does awful against OOS competition. chu was pretty dominant but his placings have gotten lower lately, losing to several people lower on the list than him.
then theres NEO who goes to a tourney even less than omni, yet is almost a guaranteed 3rd/4th/5th place at any tourney he goes to, and is a danger to anyone he faces. Boss's tourney record has a few 1st places, and a few 17th places to go with them. me and forte are sorta in that same boat, some firsts, mostly 3rd/4ths, and some losses to people lower on the list. Korn is just a basic consistent MK that refuses to enter singles tourneys, but when he does he places high.
everyone else on the list i have recognized as good players who have taken some sets off of higher placers on the list, but the 10-15 people were mostly discussed by slik/hat, i thought it looked pretty legit so i agreed.
and thats how i go about power rankings.
i have no problem with updating the list every month, why would that be silly? if that were to happen tho, than everyone would just have to trust in the panels judgement and not whine and ***** when they dont get the spot they want, they can just try to improve for next month. also, i think inactivity should drop people on the list, not so much "take them off completely", but just drop them down. for example, if candy goes to 4 tourneys in a month and gets top 4 at all of them, and omni goes to 1 tourney and gets 1st, i think candy should get the higher spot because of all the effort he is putting in. if you want to be on the panel you must prove to be seriously active to get that top spot, even if you are M2K