Oh, that was Nairo?
That shouldn't be hard as Peach has to use fair at a certain time before landing for it to be of any use and it's slow enough to be able to react to it with a practically 1 frame invincible move.
You mean frame 1. Sorry, this is a personal pet peeve of mine. When someone refers to invincibility that comes out on the very first frame, it should be referred to as "frame 1 invincibility". When a move only lasts for a frame, it's a "1 frame move". It's like the difference between a reverse B and a B-reversal. It sounds similar, but it's actually completely different.
#Nitpicking
Edit - Related fun fact: When stating the temperature, one should say, "It is X degrees Fahrenheit [or Celsius]." When stating a temperature change, or a difference between two temperatures, one should say, "The temperature rose X Fahrenheit degrees." The order means everything.....technically.
It's a bad idea. High risk low reward (unless peach is at kill %s, at which point it's high risk high reward)
If you do it right, you hit Peach with Dolphin Slash and unless you landed on the top BF platform/killed her/sent her far enough away, she can just come back and punish you with a fair or sideB or something.
If you don't do it right, you get faired...
Honestly counter is a better idea XD
But can't Marth use upB to avoid the possible grab from Peach that might be coming after the FC? You can't counter that and I don't think that Marth can do anything OoS to avoid the grab, other than roll or spot-dodge (maybe I'm wrong).
I might just leave things the way they are and let people think as they please. Even if I know deep down they are wrong on things. But i can't do anything about it. Might be best if I just gave up. And toss the goal I set out for aside. With all that said and time I spent. I actually feel horrible as a player and a person.
Don't give up, man!
If anything, hold your goals for yourself. Try to get work done in tourneys and MMs. If you can't do it yourself, then find yourself an apprentice who can see value in what you're saying (but you've gotta be able to pull it off yourself, first).
Shaya, what do you think of
-
? The chart has it as -1, but I think it's even. Marth has the tools to absolutely decimate
, but in practice it never seems to turn out that way. Would you concede to -1 or what?
About that "in practice" portion, I know I'm no high level player, but whenever I go Marth against Diddy (primarly Nuke's), I feel like I get messed up when I should have done way better. Diddy has tools that give him great shield pressure, and Marth, I feel, is kinda bad at escaping it. Like, if Marth can ever get Diddy cornered without bananas on hand, then he should just destroy him, but it's so hard to get that situation to happen consistently without screwing up and letting him escape and pull a 'naner, and once he does, life gets really hard. Marth has nice little attributes that make it so you never want to hit his shield, and that really helps him in a lot of MUs, but Diddy gets that free pressure once his banana's out. Meanwhile, Marth still isn't allowed to hit Diddy's shield so now he has to try to mindgame the heck out of Diddy's shield and either land that grab or Shield Breaker.
John's actually been telling me about a meta mindset (among many that he's 'advertised' to me
) that involves being ultra-reactionary to item play. I think that actually factored into him beating NinjaLink during the GF's of Impact. Rather than depend on regular evasion tactics, such as shields and dodges, one decides to catch everything possible. Perhaps that kind of skill and strategy makes a huge difference in the MU, but it seems extremely difficult. Sure, some of it is standard for competitive play, but to rely almost completely on that seems like it would require some beastly reaction time.
Edit: And I don't mean catching items in the air the easy way with a laxly timed AD. I mean catching everything on the ground or in the air with Z (or an appropriate attack for your situation, maybe AD if it's extremely necessary) so you can act in response as soon as possible.
Thanks for the compliment, though! 
