Results would say that you're wrong.
They 30% to death Fox, Falco, Falcon and Sheik regardless, the wobble isn't necessary to beat Jigglypuff, and it doesn't give them an edge over Peach.
Results from 2007 mean little to me.
30% to death on Falco, Fox, and Douglas is possible for sure but barring a perfect handoff the ICs player needs a whole bunch of reads on DI and combo escape options to make it happen. This is further compounded by a variety of other factors that can affect the combo's kill rate such as the YS fly guys modifying throw trajectory, Wispy blowing the lot of you closer to the edge, a platform rising beneath you courtesy of FOD, PS transforming during Nana's SH dair (resulting in a bizarre desynch), etc. Some of those stage factors are admittedly rare but there are tons of ways the environment can affect these long, moving grab sequences and they add up. Wobbling removes these complications. Aside from handoffs or the opponent's obvious unfamiliarity with a certain escape option, I seldom see an ICs go 0-death vs any of those listed characters in high profile matches aside from maybe Sheik. And that has everything to do with ICs having a legit 0-50%+ chain grab on her that she cannot do anything about if the ICs has a solid reaction because the window for regrab, dash grab, and dash JC regrab is lenient (I find it comparable to the Sheik ditto CG when I mess with it).
Wobbling just irons out all the inconsistencies in their other throw follow ups designed to maintain and keep the foe in a throw chain. It's not gamebreaking in the sense that it doesn't make them a top tier character (IMO) but to say that the character doesn't improve by having a strictly better punishment game than what they otherwise have to use seems a bit short-sighted (and it's an enormous improvement IMO, especially when you deal with lower tiered characters for both technical and practical reasons).
For what it's worth, I consider ICs in a wobbling-banned tier list the same numerical spot they occupy in a wobbling-legal one (I think I have them at 8th). But I consider the former the top of mid tier whereas I consider the latter the bottom of high tier.
------
On a totally unrelated note, I think Puff benefits from being played more aggressively in a lot of matchups than how she's currently played (which is mostly focused on [1] defending long enough to draw the foe out of position or to get them into pattern; [2] once either aforementioned misstep occurs, she tries to slip into a spot where she can threaten with one of her big plays; [3] she tries to make it happen proactively from there or tries to counter the opponent's countermeasure when they realize they're in horrible danger). I feel like her air mobility gives her a pass against a lot of defenses and functions very similarly to Peach's float except she can't land into enormous frame advantage off a godlike fair swing that covers her feet and knocks everyone down at 0 so there's more of an emphasis on maintaining mobility. I always felt Juan was 80x harder than the next best Puff largely because of how fast he felt and how openings therefore felt narrower and I feel this kind of optimized timing and action fluidity could benefit an offensive Puff style.
I find Puff hardest when I've lost positioning or she's acquired a specific type of position in relation to my own (as Sheik, when Puff is crouching in front of me when I am also on the ground I feel really limited and my first instinct is to change this position in whatever manner possible [to give an idea on how subtle these differences can be, if I'm descending from SH as she's crouching in front of me then I'm ecstatic - Puff is very detail-oriented because of her design]). Anyway, in a very general sense I feel offense does a better job than defense of acquiring those kind of relative combat positions or protecting onself from getting stuck in a bad one. Puff as a character is radically different depending on what her real estate situation is. More than any other character despite the stereotype of being functional everywhere onstage (because of her good recovery) I feel she's actually the opposite in that more than most good characters she stresses location, location, location. She gains a lot from certain positions and her options (and their relative escapability) fluctuate a lot (I feel this is why people struggle to combo with her effectively in some respects). On a related note, Puffs seriously need to learn how to combo off uair and abuse the trajectory of pound. I swear... I see so many opportunities for uair to be hit and I feel people don't know how to follow it to make the aerial chain as hard to escape as possible. There are so many rest opportunities hidden in pound's trajectory traps. And overall the combo tree is hilariously similar to Fox's. Similar principles, anyway. Weak hit attacks and limited launchers with the goal of leading into a huge hit or horizontal aerial chain. Hmm...
cuz after wobbles performance at Evo, we can probably expect IC player #s to rise in the next year or so (with 140k people watching, some of them are bound to pick up melee, and coming from other fighters w/ infinites (such as wobbling), and with wobbles being a crowd favorite, ICs seem to be an appealing character for anyone who has decided to pick up the game)
