For what it's worth, I think P:M even in it's unfinished state is miles better than Melee. Mostly due to the sheer variety of fun, unique and most importantly viable characters. The only top tier I ever enjoyed playing in Melee was Peach, all the others were pretty low, (Yoshi, DK, Ness). In P:M I'm absolutely in love with... Bowser, Ness, DDD, Snake, Yoshi, Pit, Metaknight, Diddy Kong, Lucas, Zero Suit, Peach, and I'm sure there are many, many others that I simply haven't had the time to explore that I'd also really enjoy. And they all seem viable and fun! Plus with more neutral stages it's just a much more varied game.