I will vote for the new one.
What do we think is Muddy's chances against someone like Balloon Fighter who might have a chance of fighting?
I think, personally, that while Balloon Fighter has a good chance of being a/the reto rep, Muddy Mole is in a better position only because Balloon Fighter was previously rejected by Sakurai because, at the time (during either the
Melee or
Brawl development cycle; more likely Melee, though), he couldn't figure out how to make him a viable fighter because he relies on his balloons, and what would happen if they got popped?
However, while Sakurai may not have considered Muddy Mole before (that we know of; I may be wrong on this, and if someone has any links to where Sakurai has mentioned/rejected Muddy Mole, I'd like to read them), he does not have a problem like what Balloon Fighter had (keyword "had"; Sakurai and his team is more than capable of figuring out a moveset for him, and there's the movesets in his topic as well, but that's for said topic), and he's a fairly popular retro character.
So, I'd say that Takamaru is much more of a threat than Balloon Fighter is, and between the three of them, I'd say:
- Takamaru
- Muddy Mole
- Balloon Fighter
But Takamaru and Muddy Mole are really on equal levels, and Balloon Fighter is a really close third.
----
While I did get a little off-topic to what you were asking Robotic Wind, that's what I think of the chances. Of course, somebody else may have a different opinion, or a similar opinion to my own, but worded differently, but this is my two cents.