Unofficial SWF user voted tier list - Done...

[SuSa]

Snake +1
Sheik + 1

 

[Ussi]

Pika +1
Ike +1

 

[Sage JoWii]

Kirby +1
Pit -1

 

[just86]

Yoshi +1

Pikachu +1

 

[Browny]

Wolf Sonic -1

Updated

RECENT CHANGES
Yoshi Pikachu Kirby Ike Sheik Diddy ROB Sonic Snake Falcon ZSS Peach DDD G&W +1
Wolf Pit Fox Lucario -1

 

[Nidtendofreak]

Snake +1
Lucas -1

 

[Mikachiru]

+1 Snake
+1 Falco

Dunno if I should say this or not, but it's kinda unfair that Browny puts in his vote right before an update. He goes unopposed for characters who don't get a vote at all or is netural... Not that I look at other people's posts and determine who to vote for from them. I try to choose as many different characters as possible without making the list look absurd (IE: Peach above Pikachu, Kirby below Yoshi, etc). So yeah. Completely ignore if you want, Browny. Just wanted to say.

Then again, it probably doesn't even matter lol.

<3 this thread. XD

 

[SN Viper]

i am sure he is not going to rig the list with his input as the last 2 votes but if it makes you feel better he can always be the first 2 votes instead

 

[SN Viper]

-1
+1

 

[Mikachiru]

Naw, it's cool. Don't matter to me.

It's Browny thread so he gets to do whatever he wants. XD

 

[BSP]

-1 Peach
+1 Fox

Personally, I don't think peach is still in the same level as Sonic and Fox.

 

[Spelt]

snake -1
falco -1

 

[Veel]

+1 Meta Knight
-1 Lucas

Do most people feel that Lucas is better than Ness?

Edit: My bad bra.

 

[Chuee]

Lucas +1
Ike -1 (I can play that game too Niddo >:D)
@Veel: Two only you sneaky Yoshi main.

 

[Nidtendofreak]

Lucas shouldn't be above Ness.

Dang it, I want my three votes back. I can't fight both the #2-#4 fight and Chuee at the same time with only two votes!

 

[SuSa]

Snake+1
Sheik+1

 

[Luxor]

-1 Metaknight
+1 Sonic

 

[YOSHssb]

-1 Wolf
-1 Donkey Kong

 

[phi1ny3]

Sheik +1
ZSS -1

 

[Chuee]

Hey guys we should vote down Meta knight until he isnt the best :D

 

[$up@ N0v@]

Cool thread.

TL Yoshi +1

 

[SN Viper]

Hey guys we should vote down Meta knight until he isnt the best :D

i actually want to see this succeed. so i hope you dont intentionally submit rigged votes

 

[Mikachiru]

S: Yoshi, Sonic, Peach, Flako, ZSS, Heatman, Ike, Samus, Olimar
A: Captain Fabulous, Luigi, Marf, Bowser, Tink, Snake
B: Pit, D3, PT, Sheik, GnW, Wolf, Ness, Wario, Diddy
C: Jiggs, ICs, Zelda, Link, Kirby, Pikachu, Mario
D: Lucas, Ganon, ROB, Fox, DK, Lucario
E: MK

Make this happen, guys.

srsly though, I think alot of us here won't let this happen. At least, we shouldn't...

 

[Ussi]

I will vote for what i find most out of place in the tier list, if MK isn't on top, he's getting my vote to top always

 

[Mikachiru]

I will vote for what i find most out of place in the tier list, if MK isn't on top, he's getting my vote to top always

Exactly. This is what it should be. Of course, everyone's gonna have slightly different ideas where certain characters should be (i.e. Sonic over Peach, Falco over Diddy, Jiggs being worse than Ganon, etc) but it should never turn out to resemble my awesome list. :3

 

[Browny]

Dunno if I should say this or not, but it's kinda unfair that Browny puts in his vote right before an update. He goes unopposed for characters who don't get a vote at all or is netural... Not that I look at other people's posts and determine who to vote for from them. I try to choose as many different characters as possible without making the list look absurd (IE: Peach above Pikachu, Kirby below Yoshi, etc.

I dont read anyones post before putting in my votes and I'm under the assumption that others are doing the same. I guess I'll re-add the original disclaimer about it in red text to the op and here.

If people base their votes solely to counter another persons in the thread, I will simply not include it. To show how much I dont want this to happen, I wont even tell people that im ignoring their votes in future. Its pretty easy to NOT do this, just dont vote the same character(s) in the same direction every vote or the opposite of another person repeatedly.

Pikachu Olimar +1

Updated

LATEST UPDATE
Pikachu Olimar TL Yoshi Sheik Sonic Fox Falco Snake +1
ZSS Wolf DK Ike Peach Lucas -1

That vote will not count JOE! as it was made during an update. If you want to make it count, make sure it is revelant to the current list as of right now.

 

[JOE!]

+ Link
- Wario

 

[Mikachiru]

-1 Sonic
+1 Fox

 

[Ussi]

Ike +1
Ness +1

 

[SN Viper]

+1
-1

 

[Deleted member]

Wolf +1
Lucas +1

 

[gallax]

-1

+1

-3

 

[phi1ny3]

TL -1
Snake -1

btw, under what ruleset are we assuming this is in?

 

[Browny]

Whatever ruleset you want rofl, this is unnoficial and detached from the BBR one for a reason

 

[SuSa]

Sheik + 1
Rob - 1


Lalala... til about 25-26 I think would do. We'll see after I can sort out the rest of the chars. in my mind.
But ROB sucks.

And Diddy/Snake should stay tied for 2nd, with Falco trailing at 3rd. In my personal opinion... hence me voting Snake up usually whenever he fell behind Diddy......but seeing as how I simply am unable to maintain that (as the past few updates regarding Snake has shown) I guess I'll stop my attempts and focus more on my opinion of the lower tiers.

 

[Luneth]

TL+1
Falco -1

 

[#HBC | ZoZo]

Tl -1
zss +1

 

[Hater]

Rob +1
Zelda +1

 

[Ghostbone]

+1 MK
-1 Diddy Kong

 

[rsr2]

+1 Sonic
+1 Wolf
- 1 Peach.