Oh my Jeebus... MELEE! BRAWL! MELEE! BRAWL! Who the **** even cares anymore?
At this point its just silly to continue the argument... Alex, we just have to face facts that this generation is different. The people that enjoy Brawl and these new-age, slower, casual-friendly games did not grow up with games like we did.
These teens and young adults probably started on N64 and PS1. These are the kids whose moms bought them Tomb Raider, MGS, FF7, Mario Kart 64 and Ocarina of Time. They are of the 'flash and not much substance' generation. They have been raised on the Michael Bay-style era games, that are all about flashy explosions and 'epic' cutscenes.
If you asked one of these guys to play a round of Third Strike, they would probably quit after 30 minutes because it requires them to actually think about their moves and be able to pull off such complex motions as down/down-forward+punch to throw a projectile. God help them should they actually want to do a 'combo'... Their eyes would roll back in their head at the precise timing required.
I have literally 'grown up' with gaming... I was three years old when Super Mario Bros. was first released. I learned to walk, I learned to read, I learned to write, and I learned to press A to jump over that first Goomba on World 1-1.
As I grew, so did my love for gaming and my skill at playing them. I went from never being able to leap that first pit, to being able to put the Koopa King in his place in second, more difficult quest.
Gaming and I have matured and grown together... I was there when Link defeated Ganon THE VERY FIRST TIME, and have seen him do it again dozens of times since. I was there when Kirby was still a white marshmallow, being played on a puke green portable screen. I was there when Snake first snuck his way into super-stardom. I caught all 151 original Pokemon. I was there when the 'Dream Team' gave us Crono, Marle, Frog, Robo, and all the rest. Hell, I remember when SONIC WAS STILL A GOOD SERIES...
I'm ****ing ancient, I know, and I also recognize that this is no longer my era... I can't relate to this generation... I cut my gaming teeth trying to figure out which Robot Master weapon worked best on Air Man(before I realized Metal Blade beats all
These kids are too busy screaming expletives over XBox Live Halo deathmatches to even know who Mega Man is. That's sad, to me, but hey, they don't make games for guys like me all that often these days. Sure, I'll get thrown a bone with a Bayonetta, or a retro throwback like Scott Pilgrim or Mega Man 10, but they are few and far between. Even competitive gaming has lost some of its edge... Instead of the brash, almost-insulting, New York-style trash-talk, now we have to worry about hurting each others' feelings and shake hands after the match... **** that noise.
I'm going to scream, I'm going to yell 'SHORYUKEN' and 'MISFIRE' and roll-cancel down the aisle, because everyone in the room should know that I just lit your *** on fire, and both you and I will enjoy every single minute of it. And if I don't like you, I'll let you know, not only by beating your *** in tournament, but by berating your lame-*** style of play. However, if I did that at a Brawl tournament, I'd probably get disqualified, because it disrupts my opponent... lame. I probably wouldn't win anyway, because I'd be chasing your sorry *** for 8 minutes, get bored and just lose because it's 1am, and I'm ****ing tired because this **** tournament has been running for 14 hours and we still haven't gotten to Grand Finals...
I don't even remember my point now, but basically: Play what you want, don't worry about people that don't/won't/can't play your game of choice, and most importantly-- SHUT UP AND PLAY THE **** GAME!