why not? I thought the general problem with brawl was how easy it is to compete with top players. Its the same problem with why ppl dont like MK. Difficulty rewards the player who spends time learning it. When you have something as easy as s canceling, it doesnt reward the better player. Things that add to your game and make you a better player should take time to learn and be challenging otherwise there is no point.
It's a lot
easier in Brawl, but the best players still win constantly. Plus, it's only one tactic. If the entire game was that way, then it would be a problem, but you still have to figure out how to use this most efficiently and form strategies around it. That is what will separate the noobs from the experienced players
People don't like MK because he is easy to use, yes, but it's not legitimate argument (for his ban).
no matter how easy to use they are, you can still be just as good with a harder to learn character.
For example:
In Team Fortress 2, the Pyro is undoubtedly the easiest class to play as. Therefore, lots of people play Pyro.
The Spy is undoubtedly the Hardest class to use. Therefore, the Spy requires more skill to play well compared to the Pyro.
Does this mean that the game revolves around Pyros?
No.
There are some amazing Spies out there, and some pretty good Pyros.
As long as you are willing to practice, you can be just as good with a Spy as someone can with a Pyro.
Now, does this make Pyros broken?
No. In fact I think there are a couple classes that are actually better than the Pyro. (Medic and Demo)