Generic reasons for Joey death = good.
1) He thought that Tiger was a good lynch for speculating over "obvious" things that were ultimately shown to likely be something that we didn't think it was, specifically the "town role = maker fun-er of Gorditer" (not a real quote). Tiger also explained that J may have been influenced by one of his ideas, and yet Joey kept clinging to Tiger-lynch.
2) He painted Tiger's role in as negative a light as possible, saying "the fact that a role that chooses random things to do can kill is making my stomach turn upside down" when this is COMPLETELY BASELESS. So far, all we know is one ability. That's it. But, he tried to make Tiger look like a reckless maniac due to his role. Calling something revolting isn't caution, it's fearmongering.
3) "Ninja'd so many times. He could die tonight by targeting himself. I think he should target others at first, but start targeting himself as he starts to learn his possible abilities and such." What was with the sudden change of heart? He went from "he'll kill us all!" to "target others, then himself", without any explanation.
4) Jumped on the burgeoning Gordito wagon, with only the reason that "he fell for the AtE". So, what actual reason did he vote for Gordito? He never says. For having "a mind of his own", he certainly doesn't want to let us know what's on it.
5) Do you really want someone who couldn't figure out our punishments going anywhere past D1?
6) Oooh, there it is. Joey voted for Gordito for "wasting town's time by talking about bad things". Really. Really. He talks about how Gordito is only "focusing on proving [he] is town, instead of trying to hunt for scum", but that doesn't even make sense.
7) In conjunction with point #4: After Swiss comes in and says that Gordito is clear, he unvotes without understanding why that is the case. He asks for an explanation in the same post. But, if he was so convinced, why not ask WHY his position is wrong first? Instead, he simply caved, when he realized that the support for Gordito's lynch was gone.
8) "I don't think you, swiss, or cello can win town a victory just with you three alone." This looks like it is spoken from a position of Knowledge, especially since he supposedly thinks that I'm scum. Why include me in those 3? Actually, the more I look at that, the more this particular point is steeling my resolve. It's a scum slip. If a person says "I'm a vanilla townie" 10 times and "I'm a doctor" once, does that mean he is vanilla because he said it more? No.
9) I love how he refuses to give reasons for why he thinks Pichu isn't scummy, yet demands everything from everyone else.
10) More complete flip-flop.
Joey said:
My thoughts on this game: Tiger is scummy, his claim doesn't change much for me, the fact that a role that chooses random things to do can kill is making my stomach turn upside down, and X1 was very specific with the people he chose to list, and it was really scummy.
Joey about Tiger said:
I'm not reading all the way back there to pull quotes from everything he's said. His play isn't not scummy, but it's Day 1 and we have a legit claim from what we know. I'm going to leave him at that.
He does say that he'll leave him alone, but leaves it open to come back to him "unless I can't find someone more scummy later in the day." If the claim didn't do much for him back then, how is it legit? Seems more like just wanting to evade Zen/Swiss's questions.
@MK: Reread #633 and #634, and tell me why