Mewtwo. If even Jigglypuff is in a higher tier than the supposedly "broken" Pokemon from Generation 1 of Pokemon, that's utter misrepresentation.
Ganon, Ganon, Ganon...stop waving your freakin' sword during "victory" and USE IT FOR ONCE IN YOUR LIFE TO SAVE YOUR LIFE IN SSB!! Sheesh...anytime Ganon taunts and gets KO'd, I'm gonna laugh at his stupidity for not using a sword, but pulling it out after the battle. And if the battle was a close one, that is just sad.
Jigglypuff. It is pure suckage. Enough said. (Link is NOT losing to a weird puffball lifeform!)
Brawl's CF: he doesn't suck (normally)... he's got the Falcon freakin' Punch, for goodness' sake!
Link: Has NEVER been able to rise above Low tier?! Come on...he should be able to do much better than that, considering his awesome games and all the useful abilities he employs... And a guy with a sword should not be losing to a jiggling puff! Plus, during the 1st Brawl Tier List, he was behind even Zelda (the lady he's supposed to be saving) and Ganondorf (the guy he's beaten in numerous games). That was just downright embarrassing, as another member said once...
LOL at these things said earlier in the thread: Captain Falcon just driving in his old games, the Ganondorf pic, and Zelda's "calling out to Link via dreams" as an attack. XD XD :D
And Samus may be misrepresented, but IMO, her SSB Charge Shot is PERFECT, despite not mimicking its original incarnation. The main attack that drew me into the awesome SSB series!!